- Case Report
- Open Access
Atypical chorioretinal lesions in Siberian Husky dogs with primary angle-closure glaucoma: a case series
BMC Veterinary Research volume 18, Article number: 182 (2022)
A number of etiologies for different canine chorioretinal lesions have been proved or suggested but some fundic lesions remain unclear in terms of an etiologic diagnosis, treatment options and prognosis. The purpose of this case series is to describe atypical chorioretinal lesions observed in dogs with primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG).
Two spayed-female Siberian Huskies (3- and 4-year-old) and one Siberian Husky/Australian Shepherd mixed breed dog (11-month-old) that had multifocal depigmented retinal lesions and PACG were included. Procedures: Ophthalmic examination, gross, and histopathologic examination findings are described. One of the dogs underwent further clinical diagnostics. Advanced clinical diagnostics on the fellow, presumed to be non-glaucomatous eye of a dog revealed: pectinate ligament dysplasia by gonioscopy, retinal thinning in the depigmented area and wedge shaped retinal thinning with delayed choroidal vascular perfusion by optical coherence tomography, confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy, fluorescein and indocyanine green angiography. Quantifiable maze testing for the same eye revealed mild nyctalopia but the full-field electroretinogram showed no generalized decrease of retinal function. Genetic testing for mutations within the retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator gene causing X-linked progressive retinal atrophy in Siberian Huskies was negative. Histopathologic evaluations on enucleated eyes in two dogs confirmed goniodysgenesis, PACG with optic nerve head cupping, and diffuse inner retinal atrophy. In addition, segmental profound retinal atrophy, loss of retinal pigment epithelium, and adhesion of the retina to Bruch’s membrane was observed and coincided with multifocal depigmented lesions noted on fundic examination.
To our knowledge, this is the first case series with clinical and histopathologic data of chorioretinal lesions, most likely caused by severely impaired choroidal perfusion. Further studies are warranted to elucidate the etiology and pathophysiology, including its possible association with PACG.
Etiologies of diseases in the canine fundus include hereditary and nonhereditary developmental anomalies, inherited retinal degenerations/dystrophies, nutritional deficiencies, infections, neoplasia, toxic chorioretinopathy, vascular diseases, immune mediated retinopathy, glaucoma, and trauma . Fortunately, advancement of imaging technologies and extensive studies on clinical features, pedigree analysis, and genetics of canine inherited retinal degeneration/dystrophy have resulted in improvement of clinical diagnostic abilities and the development of genetic tests and novel therapies [1,2,3]. However, even with extensive diagnostics, some clinical cases with fundic abnormalities remain unclear in terms of a definite etiologic diagnosis, thus appropriate treatment options and accurate determination of long term prognosis are hard to provide. A significant number of diseases involving the canine fundus are breed-related, suggesting possible genetic components in the pathogenesis [1, 4].
Ocular disease with possible chorioretinal changes to which Siberian Huskies are predisposed to include glaucoma, uveodermatologic syndrome (UDS), X-linked progressive retinal atrophy (PRA), and retinal dysplasia . The genetic mutation and mode of inheritance are yet to be determined in most of these diseases with exception of X-linked PRA. However, clinical features of each disease have been described in detail [1, 5].
Here, we report clinical and pathological data of unique chorioretinal changes in two spayed female Siberian Huskies and a Siberian Husky/Australian Shephard mixed breed dog with suspected primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG).
A 4-year-old, spayed female Siberian Husky was presented to the Michigan State University (MSU) Comparative Ophthalmology service seeking a second opinion on treatment of glaucoma in the left eye (OS). The owners adopted the dog as a stray approximately one year ago. Since adoption, the dog had been on a commercially available canine adult diet with addition of cooked vegetables and meat. The dog was up to date on vaccinations and heart worm preventives, and reported to be otherwise healthy.
Approximately 4 weeks prior to this visit, the dog was diagnosed with glaucoma OS by the primary veterinarian. At that time, the intraocular pressure (IOP) was 5 mmHg in the right eye (OD) and 46 mmHg OS. Then, she was seen by a boarded veterinary ophthalmologist and diagnosed with secondary glaucoma OS with a suspected underlying primary etiology of UDS. A menace response was positive OD but negative OS. Buphthalmos and optic disc cupping with loss of myelin were observed on fundic examination OS. Additionally, both eyes had multifocal patchy round, coalescing regions of depigmentation in the inferior fundus (Fig. 1). The rest of the ophthalmic examination was unremarkable. Medical treatment was started with topical 0.005% latanoprost (OS q12h), 2% dorzolamide HCl (OS q8h), and 0.5% timolol maleate (OS q8h) ophthalmic solutions for IOP control, and 1% prednisolone acetate ophthalmic solution (OD q24h and OS q12h) combined with oral prednisone 20 mg (approximately 1 mg/kg PO q12h for 1 week followed by a tapering schedule) for an anti-inflammatory and an immune-modulatory effect to treat suspected UDS.
On the first visit to MSU, the dog received a complete ophthalmic examination. The evaluation included neuro-ophthalmic evaluations, Schirmer tear test (Schirmer tear test strips, Schering-Plough Animal health, Kenilworth, NJ, USA), fluorescein staining (Flu-Glo fluorescein sodium ophthalmic strips, Akorn, Lake Forest, IL, USA), tonometry (Icare Tonovet, Vantaa, Finland), slit-lamp biomicroscopy (Kowa SL-17 portable slit lamp, Tokyo, Japan) and binocular indirect ophthalmoscopy (Keeler binocular indirect ophthalmoscope, Broomer, PA, USA ;Volk pan retinal 2.2D, Mentor, OH, USA). The examination showed OS to be non-visual, with negative direct and consensual (from OS to OD) pupillary light reflexes (PLR). The pupil was fixed mid-dilated. Additional anterior segment findings OS included buphthalmos, moderate episcleral congestion, moderate conjunctival hyperemia, lack luster corneal surface, moderate diffuse corneal edema, 1+ aqueous flare/cells, and incipient anterior cortical cataracts. Menace response was positive OD in a room-light setting, but negative in a dim-light setting. There was no abnormality noted in the anterior segment except lack luster corneal surface OD. Fundic examination showed an atapetal fundus OU, multifocal polygonal shaped depigmented lesions, the centers of which showed pigment deposits on the inferior fundus OU and optic disc cupping OS. The inferior fundus demonstrated choroidal vascular attenuation OU. The fundic changes OD were serially photo-documented with a high-resolution ocular imaging system (RetCam, Clarity Medical Systems, Pleasanton, CA, USA; Fig. 1A-E) but lesions OS, although visible with the indirect ophthalmoscope, were not photo-documented due to the limited image quality from the corneal edema. The multifocal areas of hypopigmentation in the nasal planum that the patient had were also photo-documented (Fig. 1F). Close-up images with and without a red-free filter [modified full spectrum digital single lens reflex (dSLR) camera (Canon 7D, Canon, Tokyo, Japan), dSLR camera adaptor, camera lens (Canon EF-S 60 mm f/2.8 macro lens, Canon, Tokyo, Japan) and indirect lens 40D (Volk), red-free filter (MF525/39 nm, Thorlabs, Newton, NJ)] showed central pigment deposits located over the choroidal vasculatures (Fig. 1G and H). Based on funduscopic examination and high-resolution imaging, depigmented lesions were thought to be from a lack of pigment in the RPE layer with central RPE pigment hypertrophy.
IOP measured with a rebound tonometer was 17 mmHg OD and 53 mmHg OS. Schirmer tear test values were 4 mm/min OD and 12 mm/min OS. Gonioscopy was performed OD and recorded with a high-resolution ocular-imaging system (RetCam). The iridocorneal angle OD was narrow with moderate pectinate ligament dysplasia characterized by broad-based pectinate ligament strands and solid sheets affecting approximately 70% of the angle (Fig. 2). Due to corneal edema, the iridocorneal angle (ICA) OS was not able to be examined.
Chromatic PLR (Melan-100, BioMed Vision Technologies, Ames, IA, USA) OD showed a slow incomplete response to the red light and brisk complete response to the blue light which was suggestive of decreased photoreceptor function [6, 7]. OS was not able to be tested due to corneal edema.
Quantifiable maze testing
Scotopic and photopic vision OD was tested with a custom-made obstacle-avoidance course with controlled luminance settings. Details of the course setting and the testing method have been described previously . Briefly, the dog was released at the entrance and allowed to walk through an obstacle-avoidance course. Transit time and number of bumps were recorded from the video recordings and then averaged from three runs with each approximate luminance setting at the order of: 0.02, 0.004, 0.0001, 960 and 0.02 Lux. The obstacle panel position was randomly changed for each run. In most dim light settings (0.02, 0.004, and 0.0001 Lux) with initial 20 min dark adaptation and additional 4 min adaptation for each change in setting, the dog took a longer transit time and had more bumps than average age-matched normal dogs but a shorter transit time and fewer bumps than purpose-bred research dogs with advanced progressive retinal atrophy (rcd3) with no rod function caused by PDE6A mutation (Fig. 3 ). When the test was repeated with 0.02 Lux setting after allowing a shorter dark adaptation time (4 mins) following a run with a bright luminance setting (960 Lux), the patient showed a notably poor performance compared to dogs with dogs with PDE6A mutation as well as her own records with the same light setting after 20-min dark adaptation (Fig. 3). The number of bumps and transit time of the patient was also markedly higher with 0.02 Lux after 4-min dark adaptation compared to her own records with the same light setting after 20-min dark adaptation. The results of maze testing suggested that this dog had mild to moderate nyctalopia following shorter dark adaptation time.
Electroretinography and genetic testing
Standard full-field scotopic and photopic electroretinography (ERG) was recorded OD (RETIport ERG system, Ronald Consult, Brandenburg a.d. Havel, Germany with a mini Ganzfeld stimulator, MINIGanzfeld E8, Ronald Consult, Brandenburg a.d. Havel, Germany; a Jet Electrode, Fabrinal, Eye Care, LA Chaux-De-Fonds, Switzerland and subdermal needle electrodes, Genuine Grass, Natus neurology, Galway, Ireland) under sedation with dexmedetomidine 2 μg/kg IV (Dexdomitor, Orion Corporation, Espoo, Finland). Rod- (0.01 cd.s/m2) and mixed rod-cone-mediated (3 and 10 cd.s/m2) responses were recorded after 20 mins of dark adaptation. After 5 mins of light adaptation, a single flash (3 cd.s/ m2) and 30 Hz flicker (3 cd.s/ m2) cone-mediated responses were recorded. The ERG results were unremarkable, suggesting no diffuse pathology of the retina (Fig. 4, Table 1). For comparison, Fig. 4 and Table 1 present the ERG curves and results from a normal purposed-bred dog recorded with the same system.
A blood sample was submitted for commercially available DNA testing for the mutation in retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator (RPGR) responsible for X-linked PRA in Siberian Huskies (Optigen, Ithaca, New York, USA). The test result revealed the dog was homozygous for the wild-type allele and therefore not affected by XLPRA.
Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT)
High resolution SD-OCT images (Spectralis HRA/OCT, ver. 220.127.116.11, Heidelberg Engineering, Germany) of the ocular fundus were acquired from OD under general anesthesia. The patient was pre-medicated for anesthesia with acepromazine maleate (0.03 mg/kg IM, PromAce Injectable, Boehringer Ingelheim, St. Joseph, MO, USA) and butorphanol tartrate (0.4 mg/kg IM, Torbugesic, Zoetis, Kalamazoo, MI, USA). Anesthesia was induced with propofol (3 mg/kg IV, PropoFlo, Zoetis, Kalamazoo, MI, USA) and inhalation gas anesthesia was maintained with isoflurane (Isothesia, VetUS, Dublin, OH, USA) in 100% oxygen. Horizontal volume and line scans were obtained from the superotemporal (ST), superonasal (SN), inferior (I), inferotemporal (IT), inferonasal (IN), peripapillary (PP) and optic nerve head (ONH) areas. OCT images revealed areas of multifocal depigmentation in the inferior fundus associated with partial to full thickness retinal atrophy (Fig. 5C and D): the central pigmented areas had full thickness and the depigmented surrounding areas had partial thickness loss and disruption of the retinal layers (Fig. 6A-C). Partial loss of retinal thickness was observed superior to the depigmented lesions in the inferior retina where no gross abnormality was observed on indirect ophthalmoscopy (Fig. 5C). The superior retina near the optic nerve appeared to have maintained a relatively normal structure (Fig. 5B). Within this relatively well-preserved area, the ellipsoid zone (photoreceptor inner segment/outer segment junction) appeared to be intact (Fig. 7). Additional findings included segmental partial thickness loss of the retina within the superonasal (Fig. 5A) and the superotemporal quadrants (Fig. 6D). These areas did not show any gross change on indirect ophthalmoscopy. The optic nerve head appeared normal (Fig. 5E). Peripapillary scan revealed a relatively thin retinal nerve fiber layer in the inferior retina (Fig. 5F). Additionally, the choroid was also relatively thinner in the inferior region (Figs. 5C and D and 6A-C) compared to the superior region (Fig. 5A, B). The lumens of the choroidal vessels were decreased in size which was seen as lack/decrease of hyporeflective regions within the choroid which is usually prominent in the color dilute eye. This indicated some choroidal vasculature attenuation.
Infrared imaging and fluorescein and indocyanine green angiography of the fundus
Following the OCT, additional infrared confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (cSLO) images of fundus OD were taken (Spectralis). The cSLO images showed a wedge-shaped lighter/hyperreflective lesion surrounded by a dark delineation in the superonasal fundus (Fig. 8A). This area corresponded to the area of retinal atrophy in the superonasal fundus observed with OCT (Fig. 5A). The depigmented areas in the inferior fundus appeared brighter in the cSLO imaging, which suggested more reflection from the sclera due to a thinner overlying retina and choroid (Fig. 8B). Following the cSLO imaging, a combination of fluorescein (AK-Fluor 10%, Akorn, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA; 20 mg/kg) and indocyanine green (ICG, IC-Green, Akorn, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA; 1 mg/kg) were injected IV and approximately 3 consecutive 1-min-long angiogram videos were recorded. Then, still images were taken in different areas. A delayed choroidal filling defect was observed in a wedge-shaped area of inferonasal fundus in the pre-arterial, arterial (Fig. 8C), and arteriovenous (Fig. 8D) phases. In the late phase of fluorescein angiography (FA), hyperfluorescence was observed in the depigmented lesions, likely due to a window defect caused by an absence of RPE pigment and partial loss of the retina; while those areas appeared dark in indocyanine green angiography (ICGA), suggestive of reduced perfusion/vasculature (Fig 8E and F).
Clinical findings were consistent with chronic glaucoma OS and pectinate ligament dysplasia OD, suggested PACG. The dog also had low tear production OU. However, the diagnosis of the bilateral fundic lesions and their correlation with glaucoma were unclear. Our differential diagnoses for the fundic lesions included immune-mediated chorioretinitis (i.e., UDS), developmental anomaly (i.e., hypoplasia or coloboma), inherited (i.e., PRA), secondary lesions to glaucoma/ischemia, or nutritional deficiency (i.e., previous vitamin E deficiency) based on the ophthalmoscopic appearance of the lesions and the history of being found as a stray dog.
Based on the gonioscopy results and with the aim of delaying glaucoma onset OD, a prophylactic IOP-lowering and anti-inflammatory treatment was started which included 2% dorzolamide HCl-0.5% timolol maleate ophthalmic solution (Hi-Tech Pharmacal, Amityville, NY, USA—OD q12h) and diclofenac 0.1% ophthalmic solution (Akorn, Lake Forest, IL, USA—OD q24h ). Treatment for low tear production consisted of cyclosporine 1% ophthalmic solution (compounded at MSU Veterinary Medical Center Pharmacy, East Lansing, MI, USA – OD q12h). Enucleation OS was performed under routine general anesthesia for pain control in the blind eye and the globe was submitted for histopathologic evaluation. After the enucleation procedure, 2 small biopsy samples were taken from the area of hypopigmentation in the nasal planum (Fig. 1F), for a potential diagnosis of UDS.
Gross- and histopathologic evaluation of OS revealed suspected goniodysgenesis with collapsed ciliary cleft, mild pigment dispersion, preiridal cellular to fibrous membrane, choroidal thinning and atrophy, rare axonal degeneration in the optic nerve, diffuse inner retinal atrophy, and segmental profound retinal atrophy (Fig. 9A, B and D, E). In the non-tapetal fundus with full thickness retinal atrophy, multifocal infiltrates of pigmented cells into the neural retina were observed. Multifocal loss of the RPE and adherence of the neural retina to Bruch's membrane were also noted. Nasal planum biopsy showed variable melanin pigment presence within the basal keratinocyte layers of the epidermis suggesting leukoderma or vitiligo (Fig. 9C). There were no indications of an underlying infectious, neoplastic, or autoimmune etiology in the globe or nasal planum samples (Fig. 9). These findings were consistent with chronic PACG without any evidence of uveodematologic syndrome. The etiology for the multifocal retinal atrophy was not clear.
Since initial presentation to MSU, recheck examinations have been performed every 1-3 months. The IOPs OD have been maintained within normal range (8 – 14 mmHg), and no gross progressive changes have been observed on ophthalmic examinations (Fig. 1C, D, and E). On the most recent examinations—performed 2-year following initial presentation— menace response was positive OD in a room-light setting, but negative in a dim-light setting, which was subjectively unchanged from the initial visit. At follow-up visits, the dog was not subjected to quantifiable maze testing. There have been no clinical sign of active inflammation. STT OD was measured at 13 mm/min and signs of xerosis on the cornea have markedly improved.
A 3-year-old, spayed female Siberian Husky was diagnosed with primary glaucoma OU and medically managed by the Ophthalmology Services at Colorado State University (CSU) Veterinary Teaching Hospital and VRCC Veterinary Specialty and Emergency Hospital. At the time of first examination at CSU, the OD was blind but OS was visual. The IOP was 34 mmHg OD and 13 mmHg OS measured with a Tono-Pen Avia® Vet (Reichert Inc., Depew, NY 14843). Gonioscopy OS (Koeppe Goniolens, Ocular, Bellevue, WA 98004) revealed no visible pectinate ligament with closed iridocorneal angle. Indirect ophthalmoscopy and fundic imaging (Optibrand’s Clearview Fundic Camera, Fort Collins, CO) revealed an atapetal fundus OD (Fig. 10A and B) and a small tapetum OS (Fig. 10C). In the inferior fundus OD, there was a wedge-shaped area without retinal vessels and decreased central RPE pigment with focal areas of increased pigment (Fig. 10A). Two small circular lesions with lack of pigmentation were observed in the inferotemporal fundus OD, but the underlying choroidal vessels were visible (Fig. 10B). The optic disc appeared dark and cupped OD (Fig. 10A) and normal in size but pale OS (Fig. 10D). No chorioretinal lesions were noted OS throughout the 8-month of follow-up.
Medical treatments included 2% dorzolamide HCl (Akorn, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA, OU q8h), 0.5% timolol maleate (Akorn, Lake Forest, Illinois, USA, OU q12h), and 0.005% latanoprost ophthalmic solutions (Bausch and Lomb, Bridgewater, NJ, USA – OU q12h). OD was enucleated approximately 7 months after the initial diagnosis due to uncontrolled IOP. Gross and histopathologic evaluation revealed goniodysgenesis, buphthalmos, iridocorneal angle descemetization, pre- and post-iridal fibrovascular membranes, mild lymphoplasmacytic anterior uveitis, trabecular meshwork pigment dispersion, and broad posterior synechiae (Fig. 11). While follow up fundus images were not obtained, comparison of images from the initial examination with the gross eye image after enucleation suggested progression of the chorioretinal lesions (Fig. 11A). Similar to case 1, diffuse full thickness atrophy of the choroid and retina, RPE degeneration, hypertrophy and hyperplasia with sub- and intra-retinal pigment dispersion were also observed (Fig. 11B and C).
An 11-month-old, spayed female Siberian Husky-Australian Shepherd mixed breed dog was diagnosed with primary glaucoma OD and pectinate ligament dysplasia OU (Fig. 12A and B) and medically managed by the MSU Comparative Ophthalmology service. At the time of first examination OD was blind but OS was visual. The IOP was 18 mmHg OD and 7 mmHg OS measured with a rebound tonometer. Gonioscopy was performed OS and recorded with a high-resolution ocular-imaging system (RetCam, Fig. 12A and B) and revealed severe pectinate ligament dysplasia. OD had buphthalmos, posterior subcapsular cataract with equatorial vacuoles (Fig. 12C and D). Aphakic cresent was also observed OU. Indirect ophthalmoscopy and fundic imaging revealed an atapetal fundus OU (Fig. 12E and F), a wedge-shaped area OD with multifocal polygonal shaped depigmented lesions, the centers of which showed pigment deposits and choroidal vessel attenuation, 2 wedge-shaped areas with choroidal vessel attenuations in the superior and superonasal fundus, and optic disc cupping OD (Fig. 12E and F). The fundus OS was normal over the entire follow-up period. Medical treatments included 2% dorzolamide HCl-0.5% timolol maleate (Hi-Tech Pharmacal, Amityville, NY, USA—OU q12h) and latanoprost (Bausch and Lomb, Bridgewater, NJ, USA – OD q12h). Over the follow-up period of 11 months, despite no recorded IOP spikes, the chorioretinal lesions progressed with an increased number of wedge shaped areas with choroidal vessel attenuation in the superior and inferior fundus and pigment changes in the inferior fundus (Fig. 12G and H).
Discussion and conclusions
We report three comparable cases of glaucoma with unique multifocal hypopigmented chorioretinal lesions in two Siberian Huskies and a Siberian Husky/Australian Shepherd mixed breed dog with extensive clinical diagnostic data in one of these dogs, including color and infrared cSLO fundic images, FA, ICGA, OCT, quantitative maze test, ERG, genetic test, and histopathology. All dogs were young adult spayed females between 11 months and 4 years of age. This report provides detailed clinical and pathological documentations of multifocal hypopigmented retinopathy associated with PAG in two purebred and a mixed Siberian Huskies.
Paving-stone retinal degeneration in humans
Comparable retinal lesions as noted in the current case series have been described as paving-stone or cobblestone retinal degeneration in humans [10, 11]. The funduscopic and OCT images as well as histologic description reported in humans are consistent with observations in our canine patients [10,11,12,13,14], with multiple, small, well-demarcated flat lesions. Irregular black pigmentation is frequently present along the margins of the lesions. OCT and histology in humans have demonstrated marked thinning of the neural retina with RPE loss and with RPE hyperplasia surrounding these regions [10,11,12,13]. It has been suggested that these changes are associated with choroidal vascular insufficiencies and are consistent with OCT and angiographic findings in our case 1. In humans, similar chorioretinal lesions have also been reported in patients with pathologic myopia, inherited retinal dysplasia, such as gyrate atrophy, and choroidal neoplasms, including malignant melanoma and metastatic carcinoma [12, 14,15,16]. However, approximately 15% of autopsied human eyes with or without other ocular pathology were also reported to have paving-stone degeneration, and 38% of the cases were bilateral . Therefore, direct relationship of paving-stone degeneration to any specific ocular diseases remains unknown.
Differential etiological diagnoses
Siberian Huskies are predisposed to develop primary glaucoma with pectinate ligament dysplasia; this condition has been reported more frequently in young and middle-age females [17, 18]. However, the mode of inheritance or genetic mutation associated with this disease has not been determined . While cases presented in the present report were all young spayed females with blue irides that perfectly fit previous descriptions of this breed’s predisposition for primary glaucoma, chorioretinal changes observed have not been reported to be associated with glaucoma in Siberian Huskies or in any other breed. A variety of diagnoses can be made based on the multifocal depigmented retinal lesions in this breed. Possible etiological diagnoses include developmental anomaly, immune-mediated disease, inherited PRA/dystrophy, nutritional deficiency, secondary to glaucoma/ischemia, or any combination of these.
Differential diagnosis: developmental anomalies
Developmental anomalies of the fundus reported in dogs include Collie eye anomaly, with choroidal hypoplasia, optic disc coloboma, and/or retinal detachment, merle ocular dysgenesis, retinal dysplasia, and canine multifocal retinopathy . Chorioretinal colobomas also have been reported in human patients, but they are usually accompanied by retinal detachment [19, 20]. Recently, a chorioretinal coloboma has been reported in a Golden Retriever with FA and OCT data . Although clinical signs and diagnostic results do not resemble any of the reported developmental anomalies in dogs, abnormal development of the RPE and neuroretina is a possibility, especially given the subalbinotic features of the dogs described herein.
Differential diagnosis: inflammation
Chronic inflammation, including immune-mediated chorioretinitis, has been described to cause multifocal depigmentation with retinal and choroidal vessel attenuation . RPE pigment migration in the center of depigmented lesions suggest that those lesions are potentially post-inflammatory. Another possible differential was UDS given the clinical presentation of depigmented fundic changes combined with vitiligo on the nasal planum; Siberian Huskies are predisposed to this disease . UDS was considered less likely to play a role in our cases because of no significant anterior uveitis or evidence of active inflammation in the histopathologic evaluation of the two globes and nasal planum. Immune-mediated etiology cannot, however, be completely excluded because one of the dogs was on a tapering dose of systemic prednisone as well as topical prednisolone acetate prior to enucleation and nasal biopsy. Additionally, the absence of active inflammation does not rule out the possibility of an inactive stage of an immune-mediated disease process.
Differential diagnosis: X-linked PRA
Multifocal depigmented lesions with early nyctalopia followed by a complete loss of vision have been described in PRA in the Tibetan Terrier [22, 23], and cone-rod dystrophy (crd) in miniature long-haired dachshunds . The Siberian Husky has been described as having X-linked PRA with a mutation of the RPGR gene . Reported clinical signs associated with X-linked PRA include initial nyctalopia, ophthalmoscopic signs of retinal degeneration, and diminished rod-mediated function observed at 2-4 years of age . Although the age of 2 dogs and the observed nyctalopia in 1 dog (vision testing results with different light settings were not available for the other two dogs) were consistent with clinical features of X-linked PRA, normal ERG findings and a negative genetic test result in 1 dog ruled out X-linked PRA due to a RPGR mutation. Other types of inherited retinal degeneration, however, cannot be completely ruled out. Unfortunately, pedigree information was not available for any patient. Future studies on pedigree analysis will help investigate the genetic contribution of this disease. ERG recording with dim flashes during dark adaptation, as suggested in the first canine ERG protocol, might have supported the findings of abnormal dark adaptation in quantifiable maze tests . It was not possible to run the tests due to insufficient sedation during dark adaptation.
Differential diagnosis: nutritional deficiency
As one of the patients had been a stray, another consideration was previous nutritional deficiency. Vitamin E deficiency in particular has been reported to manifest as multifocal retinal lesions in dogs and horses and its relationship with retinal pigmented epithelial dystrophy has been suggested among several canine breeds [27,28,29,30]. Nutritional etiology is made less likely by a lack of evidence of hyperfluorescent lipofuscin accumulation on cSLO and histologic evidence of vitamin E deficiency and the incidence of 3 cases with similar signalment and clinical presentations in geographically different locations.
Differential diagnosis: ischemia
A final possible etiology is retinal atrophy secondary to increased IOP and ischemia. In case 1, glaucoma was documented OS with chorioretinal lesions being observed OU. While intermittent subclinical IOP spikes may have contributed to noted retinal changes OD, there has been no documented IOP elevation over a 21-month follow up period. Conversely, the retinal lesions were observed OD only in the case 2 while the patient had chronic glaucoma OU. Considering OS had a small area of tapetum and relatively more RPE pigment than OD, one could hypothesize that less pigmented eyes are more susceptible to the potential ischemic damage. The wedge-shaped retinal atrophy observed with IR cSLO and the delayed choroidal filling in the FA and ICGA in case 1 are highly suggestive of ischemic lesions along watershed zones. In case 1, choroidal thinning associated to choroidal vasculature attenuation was also noted inferiorly. This was seen as a decrease in the lumen size of the choroidal vessels on OCT high-resolution cross-sections, which could further support the hypothesis of ischemia. Histopathologic evaluation confirmed choroidal thinning and atrophy in cases 1 and 2. In dogs, nonhuman primates, and humans pyramidal-shaped areas of choroidal and retinal degenerations extending from the optic nerve head consistent with watershed zones have been described with marked IOP elevations [17, 31, 32]. Anterior ischemic optic neuropathies caused by atherosclerosis and non-arteritic etiologies have also been reported to cause watershed zones in angiograms [33, 34]. Watershed zones were also observed in human patients with normotensive glaucoma and 46-90% of human subjects with no known ocular disease [35,36,37]. Retinal angiography is relatively infrequently performed in veterinary patients, but based on our experience with healthy research dogs without any known ocular or systemic diseases, watershed zones can also be found sporadically in normal canine eyes with FA and ICGA (data not shown). Thus, the watershed zones found in our patients do not confirm an ischemic etiology.
The pattern and dimensions of the chorioretinal lesions resemble lobules served by choroidal end arterioles which may further support ischemic etiology. A recent manuscript on decreased luminal areas of the short posterior ciliary arteries in dogs with glaucoma supports the potential ischemic etiology associated with decreased choroidal perfusion in these cases .
Ellipsoid zone in OCT
The integrity of the ellipsoid zone in OCT indicates normal alignment of membranous discs in the photoreceptor outer segments, which is necessary for the normal functioning of photoreceptors. In humans, an intact subfoveal ellipsoid zone is highly correlated with visual acuity, and disrupted or absent ellipsoid zone has been reported with a number of retinal diseases . While the dog in case 1 exhibited decreased visual function under dim light conditions, the ellipsoid zone at least in well-preserved retinal regions appeared to be normal.
To summarize, we present 3 Siberian Huskies with multifocal, moderate to severe retinal atrophies with depigmented retinal lesions in the inferior fundus along with wedge-shaped areas of choroidal vessel attenuation in the superior fundus. IR cSLO, FA, and ICGA in 1 dog revealed delayed perfusion along watershed zones, which were correspondent to the area with retinal thinning in OCT. The dog had reduced night vision, but full-field ERG failed to detect any abnormality. It must be noted that the ERG, OCT and vision testing results for the normal dogs shown in this manuscript is to provide some reference to the readers, not intended to directly compare the data. Ideally, those data should be compared with age-, sex-, breed- matched dogs with similar amount of ocular pigmentation. Histology of the enucleated glaucomatous eyes in 2 dogs showed segmental partial to full thickness retinal atrophy with loss of RPE as shown in the OCT of the fellow non-glaucomatous eye in a dog. These findings are consistent with paving-stone degeneration of the retina in humans. No active signs of inflammation were observed in either globe or nasal planum sample.
While a definitive etiologic diagnosis could not be made, the authors hope that this report with extensive diagnostic data will bring our colleagues’ attention to this disease and stimulate discussions and studies with an accumulated number of patients with long-term follow-ups. We further hope that such studies will shed light on etiology, genetics, pathophysiology, and prognosis, resulting in the development of therapies.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article
Confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy
Colorado State University
Digital single lens reflex
Indocyanine green angiography
Michigan State University
Optic nerve head
Primary angle-closure glaucoma
Pupillary light reflexes
Progressive retinal atrophy
Retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator
Narfstrom K, Petersen-Jones SM: Diseases of the canine ocular fundus. Veterinary ophthalmology. 5th. Gelatt KN, Gilger BC, Kern TJ. Ames IA, USA: Wiley; 2013: 1303-1392.
Petersen-Jones SM, Komaromy AM. Dog models for blinding inherited retinal dystrophies. Human Gene Ther Clin Dev. 2015;26(1):15–26.
Petersen-Jones SM, Clements PJ, Barnett KC, Sargan DR. Incidence of the gene mutation causal for rod-cone dysplasia type 1 in Irish setters in the UK. J Small Anim Pract. 1995;36(7):310–4.
Winkler PA, Occelli LM, Petersen-Jones SM. Large animal models of inherited retinal degenerations: a review. Cells. 2020;9(4):882.
Genetics Committee of the American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists. Ocular disorders presumed to be inherited in purebred dogs. 11th ed: American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists; 2018.
Grozdanic SD, Matic M, Sakaguchi DS, Kardon RH. Evaluation of retinal status using chromatic pupil light reflex activity in healthy and diseased canine eyes. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2007;48(11):5178–83.
Yeh CY, Koehl KL, Harman CD, Iwabe S, Guzman JM, Petersen-Jones SM, et al. Assessment of rod, cone, and intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cell contributions to the canine chromatic pupillary response. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2017;58(1):65–78.
Garcia MM, Ying GS, Cocores CA, Tanaka JC, Komaromy AM. Evaluation of a behavioral method for objective vision testing and identification of achromatopsia in dogs. Am J Vet Res. 2010;71(1):97–102.
Miller PE, Schmidt GM, Vainisi SJ, Swanson JF, Herrmann MK. The efficacy of topical prophylactic antiglaucoma therapy in primary closed angle glaucoma in dogs: a multicenter clinical trial. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc. 2000;36(5):431–8.
O'Malley P, Allen RA, Straatsma BR, O'Malley CC. Paving-stone degeneration of the retina. Arch Ophthalmol. 1965;73:169-82.
Ghazi NG, Dibernardo C, Ying H, Mori K, Gehlbach PL. Optical coherence tomography of peripheral retinal lesions in enucleated human eye specimens with histologic correlation. Am J Ophthalmol. 2006;141(4):740–2.
Brown GC, Shields JA. Choroidal melanomas and paving stone degeneration. Ann Ophthalmol. 1983;15(8):705–8.
Choudhry N, Golding J, Manry MW, Rao RC. Ultra-widefield steering-based spectral-domain optical coherence tomography imaging of the retinal periphery. Ophthalmology. 2016;123(6):1368–74.
Grossniklaus HE, Green WR. Pathologic findings in pathologic myopia. Retina (Philadelphia, Pa). 1992;12(2):127–33.
Doguizi S, Sekeroglu MA, Anayol MA, Yilmazbas P. Arginine-testricted therapy resistant bilateral macular edema associated with gyrate atrophy. Case Rep Ophthalmol Med. 2015;2015:137270.
Zhang T, Zuo Y, Wei Y, Huang W, Zhou X, Liu R, et al. The prevalence and associations of peripheral retinopathy: baseline study of Guangzhou office computer workers. J Ophthalmol. 2018;2018:2358690.
Plummer CE, Regnier A, Gelatt KN. The canine glaucoma. In: Gelatt KN, Gilger BC, Kern TJ, editors. Veterinary ophthalmology. 5th ed. Ames: Wiley Blackwell; 2013. p. 1050–145.
Gelatt KN, MacKay EO. Prevalence of the breed-related glaucomas in pure-bred dogs in North America. Veterinary ophthalmology. 2004;7(2):97–111.
Abouammoh MA, Alsulaiman SM, Gupta VS, Younis A, Chhablani J, Hussein A, et al. Surgical outcomes and complications of rhegmatogenous retinal detachment in eyes with chorioretinal coloboma: The Results of the KKESH International Collaborative Retina Study Group. Retina. 2017;37(10):1942-1947.
Wei Y, Li Y, Chen F. Vitrectomy treatment of retinal detachments related to choroidal coloboma involving the disk. Retina (Philadelphia, Pa). 2014;34(6):1091–5.
Gonzalez-Alonso-Alegre EM, Rodriguez-Alvaro A, Esteban-Martin J. Atypical chorioretinal coloboma in a Golden Retriever: a retinographic, fluoroangiographic, and optical coherence tomography study. Vet Ophthalmol. 2016;19(6):525–30.
Nafstrom K, Petersen-Jones SM. Disease of the canine ocular fundus. In: Gelatt KN, Gilger BC, Kern TJ, editors. Vetreinary Ophthalmology. 5th ed. Ames: Wiley; 2013. p. 1303–76.
Millichamp NJ, Curtis R, Barnett KC. Progressive retinal atrophy in Tibetan terriers. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 1988;192(6):769–76.
Curtis R, Barnett KC. Progressive retinal atrophy in miniature longhaired dachshund dogs. Bri Vet J. 1993;149(1):71–85.
Acland GM, Blanton SH, Hershfield B, Aguirre GD. XLPRA: a canine retinal degeneration inherited as an X-linked trait. American journal of medical genetics. 1994;52(1):27–33.
Ekesten B, Komaromy AM, Ofri R, Petersen-Jones SM, Narfstrom K. Guidelines for clinical electroretinography in the dog: 2012 update. Document Ophthalmol Adv Ophthalmol. 2013;127(2):79–87.
Davidson MG, Geoly FJ, Gilger BC, McLellan GJ, Whitley W. Retinal degeneration associated with vitamin E deficiency in hunting dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 1998;213(5):645–51.
McLellan GJ, Bedford PG. Oral vitamin E absorption in English Cocker Spaniels with familial vitamin E deficiency and retinal pigment epithelial dystrophy. Vet Ophthalmol. 2012;15(Suppl 2):48–56.
McLellan GJ, Cappello R, Mayhew IG, Elks R, Lybaert P, Watte C, et al. Clinical and pathological observations in English cocker spaniels with primary metabolic vitamin E deficiency and retinal pigment epithelial dystrophy. Vet Record. 2003;153(10):287–92.
Riis RC, Jackson C, Rebhun W, Katz ML, Loew E, Summers B, et al. Ocular manifestations of equine motor neuron disease. Equine Vet J. 1999;31(2):99–110.
Gum GG, Mackay EO. Physiology of the eye. In: Gelatt KN, Gilger BC, Kern TJ, editors. Veterinary ophthalmology. 5th ed. Ames: Wiley-Blackwell; 2013. p. 171–207.
Hayreh SS. In vivo choroidal circulation and its watershed zones. Eye (London, England). 1990;4(Pt 2):273–89.
Utsugi N, Takahashi K, Kishi S. Choroidal vascular occlusion in internal carotid artery obstruction. Retina (Philadelphia, Pa). 2004;24(6):915–9.
Oto S, Yilmaz G, Cakmakci S, Aydin P. Indocyanine green and fluorescein angiography in nonarteritic anterior ischemic optic neuropathy. Retina (Philadelphia, Pa). 2002;22(2):187–91.
Ito YN, Mori K, Young-Duvall J, Yoneya S. Aging changes of the choroidal dye filling pattern in indocyanine green angiography of normal subjects. Retina (Philadelphia, Pa). 2001;21(3):237–42.
Giuffre G. Main posterior watershed zone of the choroid. Variations of its position in normal subjects. Doc Ophthalmol Adv Ophthalmol. 1989;72(2):175–80.
Sato Y, Tomita G, Onda E, Goto Y, Oguri A, Kitazawa Y. Association between watershed zone and visual field defect in normal tension glaucoma. Japan J Ophthalmol. 2000;44(1):39–45.
Fick CM, Dubielzig RR. Short posterior ciliary artery anatomy in normal and acutely glaucomatous dogs. Vet Ophthalmol. 2016;19(1):43–9.
Murthy RK, Haji S, Sambhav K, Grover S, Chalam KV. Clinical applications of spectral domain optical coherence tomography in retinal diseases. Biomed J. 2016;39(2):107–20.
Park SA, Dodd S, Leandro T, Boyd R, Freeman K, Koehl K, et al. Paving-stone degeneration-like retinal lesions in young adult Siberian Husky dogs with primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG). In: 10th Annual 2017 Midwest Eye Research Symposium. Iowa City; 2017.
The authors thank Drs. Susette Aquino, Gwen Sila, and Matthew Chavkin for providing clinical information on these dogs. This work was presented at the 10th annual 2017 Midwest Eye Research Symposium .
Part of the study was funded by Gary L. Blanchard Fund, Comparative Ophthalmology Service, Michigan State University, the National Eye Institute/National Institutes of Health grant R01-EY025752 (AMK) and K08EY030950 (SAP). There was no role of the funding body in the design of the study, data collection or analysis, interpretation of data or in writing the manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
Written informed consent to perform all the examinations and diagnostics presented in this manuscript was obtained from the owners of the animals.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Park, S.A., Sledge, D., Monahan, C.F. et al. Atypical chorioretinal lesions in Siberian Husky dogs with primary angle-closure glaucoma: a case series. BMC Vet Res 18, 182 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12917-022-03259-8