- Research article
- Open Access
Cross-sectional study of Schmallenberg virus seroprevalence in wild ruminants in Poland at the end of the vector season of 2013
BMC Veterinary Researchvolume 10, Article number: 967 (2014)
In view of recurrent Schmallenberg virus (SBV) infections all over Europe between 2011 and 2013, a lively scientific debate over the importance of the sylvatic transmission cycle of the virus has emerged. The study presents results of serosurvey which included wild ruminants representing species of red deer (Cervus elaphus), roe deer (Capreolus capreolus), European bison (Bison bonasus), fallow deer (Dama dama), mouflon (Ovis orientalis musimon) hunted or immobilized at 34 different locations of Poland in the autumn/winter 2013.
Out of 580 sera, 145 (25%) were considered positive for SBV antibodies. The overall SBV seroprevalence calculated using district probability weights was estimated at 27.7% (95% CI: 24.0-31.4). The seroprevalences at the district level varied between 0 and 80.0% (95% CI: 24.5-135.0%) with the mean within-district prevalence of 24.0% (95% CI: 16.5-31.4). Significantly higher seroprevalence was observed in animals from the Eastern provinces (36.6%) compared to the Western provinces (22.8%). SBV infection impact varied significantly between different species (higher SBV seroprevalence in larger species such as European bison), population type (free-ranging; captive), age, body weight, percent of the district forest area, part of Poland, and the densities of wild and domestic ruminants at the district and province level. Using statistical multivariable logistic model, population type, age, part of Poland and domestic ruminant density were identified as the main risk factors for SBV infection in wild ruminants in Poland.
SBV seroprevalence in wild ruminants, similarly to the epizootic situation in domestic ruminants in the country, varied significantly between districts and provinces. Association between SBV seropositivity, species, animal body weight and age group expressed by a higher prevalence in larger ruminants may be explained by more frequent exposure to midge-vector bites of the latter, however it might also be related to the different species susceptibility to SBV infection. The positive effect of higher domestic ruminant density on the risk of SBV infection in wildlife and lower SBV seroprevalences in the latter suggested that the sylvatic cycle of SBV transmission is an effect of the pathogen spillover from the domestic animals.
Schmallenberg virus (SBV) is a novel Orthobunyavirus infecting ruminants which emerged in North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany in August/September 2011 . SBV transmission occurs through midge vectors and infection is mostly sub-clinical in adult animals . The virus infections in pregnant domestic ruminants were observed to provoke abortions, stillbirths and, most frequently, congenital musculoskeletal and neural malformations observed in new-born animals leading to their death shortly after birth . In view of recurrent SBV infections all over Europe, lively scientific debate over the importance of the sylvatic transmission cycle of the virus has emerged . SBV infection has been already reported in the wildlife in Poland . This study presents wider perspective of SBV infections in wild ruminants in Poland.
A total of 580 serum samples collected during collective hunting or from immobilized, selectively culled or fallen red deer (Cervus elaphus) (n = 176), roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) (n = 66), European bison (Bison bonasus) (n = 11), fallow deer (Dama dama) (n = 256), and mouflon (Ovis orientalis musimon) (n = 71) were tested. The samples were collected during the hunting season 2013/2014 (from 25 October 2013 until 29 January 2014) from animals originating from 34 forest districts (23 located on the Western side of Vistula river, assigned as Western Poland in the statistical analysis). The study was based on a cross-sectional design aiming to estimate the prevalences of infections with BVDV and BoHV-1. The density of wild ruminant population and species composition according to the information provided by the National Forest Holding  and published by Central Statistical Office  were considered when selecting the distribution of sampling sites and the number of animals. The average number of animals sampled was 17.1 (95% CI: 3.5-30.7) per district. The species were homogenously distributed per district, except for European bison and mouflon which originated from two districts with the largest population sizes in Białowieża Primeval Forest (East Poland, near Białystok) and Pławin (West Poland, near Szczecin) (Figure 1), respectively. Cervid samples were collected during collective hunting according to the appropriate Polish legislation , or in case of the farmed animals by mechanical immobilization. No ethical/welfare authority approval was required as samples were collected post-mortem or obtained at the request of the owner for diagnostic purposes from live animals immobilized by certified veterinarians. The European bison were sampled after chemical immobilization  or culling by certified hunters in accordance with the appropriate regulations . The blood was collected into sterile tubes with clot activator and gel for serum separation from the external jugular vein, heart and body cavities from dead animals, while it was drawn from jugular vein from the immobilized ones. Sampling date, location, gender and body weights were recorded. More females (n = 307) than males (n = 133) were sampled, while the information of the gender was missing for 140 animals. The average age was 3.2 (95% CI: 2.8-3.7) years. The majority of samples (n = 539) derived from animals older than one year. The oldest ruminants tested were European bison with the average age of 12.6 (95% CI: 8.2-17.1) years. The body weight data was available for 345 animals with the average of 64.7 (95% CI 57.0-72.4) kg. The continuous values were transformed into ordinal variables for the statistical analysis. The body weights were associated with the animal species with the mean values of 17.4 (95% CI: 14.9-19.8), 23.7 (95% CI: 16.9-30.4), 55.4 (95% CI: 72.2-82.0), 77.1 (95% CI: 72.2-82.0) and 382 (95% CI: 82.2-681.7) kg for roe deer, mouflon, fallow deer, red deer and European bison, respectively.
Serological ID Screen Schmallenberg Virus Competition Multi-Species ELISA (ID.vet, France) for the detection of antibodies against SBV nucleoprotein was performed according to the manufacturer’s instruction. The results were interpreted on the S/P values calculated from the optical density (O.D.) values measured at 450 nm using the following equation: O.D. sample tested – O.D. negative control / O.D. positive control – O.D. negative control × 100. The S/P values below and equal to 40% were considered positive, S/P value above 50% - negative, and the S/P value between 40% and 50% doubtful.
Virus neutralization test (VNT)
Randomly selected non hemolyzed serum samples giving negative (n = 20), positive (n = 50) and doubtful (n = 12) results by c-ELISA were verified by virus neutralization test. The sera were heat-inactivated at 56°C for 30 min beforehand. Serial two-fold dilutions of the sera (starting from 1:4 up to 1:4096) in Glasgow Minimum Essential Medium (GMEM) were incubated for 1–1.5 h at 37°C in a 96-well microplate with approx. 500 TCID50 of the Polish SBV strain 130/6 isolated from the cerebrum of ovine fetus. The sera were tested in duplicate. The strain was passaged 3 times in baby hamster kidney (BHK-21) cells with the final titer of 8 × 104 TCID50. Back titration of virus was included in each assay by performing four 10-fold dilutions of the virus working solution. Two wells with 1:4 dilution of each serum were left uninfected as a serum cytotoxity control. Similarly diluted negative (commercial foetal bovine serum negative in ELISA) and positive (bovine sample from a confirmed SBV outbreak) serum samples were tested simultaneously. After the incubation, each well was overlaid with approx. 104 BHK-21 cells and the plates were incubated for five days at 37°C in 5% CO2. After fixation in 80% chilled acetone, drying, staining with 0.1% crystal violet and washing, the plates were examined under the microscope. Serum was considered as a VNT positive if the viral CPE inhibition was observed in at least one of two wells at a dilution ≥1:4. The titer of tested serum sample was assumed as the reciprocal of the highest dilution of the sample for which none or one of the wells of a dilution showed any cytopathic effect.
Statistical analysis was performed using STATA v. 13.0 software (StataCorp LP, Texas, USA). The prevalences were corrected by the population probability weights (pweights) calculated as follows: 1/(n of sampled animals/N of animals in the forest district). The latter together with forest density data was obtained from the General Directorate of National Forest Holding . The densities of livestock at the province level derived from yearbooks of Central Statistical Office . The associations between the gender, age group, body weight, population type (free-ranging; captive), geographic location, part of the country (Western; Eastern), wild and domestic ruminant densities per km2 and SBV seroprevalence were estimated using χ2, Spearman test and odds ratio (OR) calculated by univariate logistic regression. The variables are explained in detail in Table 1. In order to asses the risk factors of SBV seropositivity, mixed-effects logistic regression model accounting for species as fixed effect was compiled using backward procedure. The district-level wild ruminant density and body weight group variables were removed from the model due to collinearity (Spearman coefficient ρS > 0.5; p < 0.05).
Results and discussion
Based on c-ELISA, of 580 serum samples 136 (23.4%), 29 (4.8%) and 415 (71.6%) were considered positive, doubtful and negative for the presence of SBV antibodies, respectively. The Kernel density plot showed clear bimodal ELISA S/P value distribution divided by the cut-off value (Figure 2). Some selected for their good quality, non hemolyzed sera were tested with VNT. The c-ELISA positive (n = 50) and negative (n = 20) results were confirmed consistent by VNT, while 9 (75%) and 3 (25%) out of 12 c-ELISA doubtful sera were VNT positive and negative, respectively. The mean VNT titers of c-ELISA positive and doubtful sera were 560.3 (95% CI: 324,7-796.0) and 210.3 (95% CI: −47.9-468.4), respectively. For further analysis, the number of SBV seropositive wild ruminants was adjusted according to VNT results at 145 (25%) animals, while the rest of the doubtful sera (n = 17) unsuitable for VNT due to their cytotoxity were considered negative. The problem of poor quality samples originating from wildlife and the usefulness of confirmatory tests was discussed in detail by Casaubon et al.  in a similar serosurvey of bluetongue virus in free-ranging cervids and wild Caprine. Another possible bias derives from the differences in ELISA and VNT sensitivities. In serology, VNT is considered as a gold standard and used as a confirmatory method to the commercial tests also in SBV epidemiology. The same c-ELISA (ID.vet) was successfully used in other wild ruminant studies before -, however Laloy et al.  have pointed out the possible disagreements between the two methods. In their study, c-ELISA has failed to detect 30 out of 97 (30.1%) VNT positive results of red deer sera, while the false positive ratio reached 35.3%.
Using the forest district population weights, the overall SBV seroprevalence was estimated at 27.7% (95% CI: 24.0-31.4). The percentage of SBV seropositive wild ruminants was slightly lower than the apparent seroprevalences for wild ungulates observed at the beginning of the European epizootic in Belgium (43.1%)  and in UK (approx. 56% in fallow deer and 71% in red deer) in 2012 . In Poland, after the first detection of SBV infection in domestic ruminants during summer of 2012 ,, SBV transmission to free-ranging red deer in Western and European bison in Eastern Poland were detected in November 2012 . The seroprevalence in wild ruminants was comparable to the value of 35.6% observed in domestic ruminants in Poland in 2013  which suggests similar exposure to SBV infection. It is consistent with the observation of the ecosystem of Spanish hunting estate where SBV seroprevalence in roe deer (80%) was almost identical to the cattle herds (86.8%) reared in the area .
The SBV seroprevalences of the 34 forest districts included in the study ranged between 0 and 80.0% (95% CI: 24.5-135.0%) with the mean within-district prevalence of 24.0% (95% CI: 16.5-31.4) (Figure 1). No seropositive wild ruminants were found in nine (26.5%) districts of which seven were located in Western Poland. Significant associations between SBV seroprevalence and environment conditions such as part of the country where the animals originated from, the percent of forest area in the district and wild and domestic ruminant densities were also found (Table 1). Higher proportion of SBV seropositive wild ruminants was found in Eastern Poland, in the districts with higher percent of forest area and in the provinces characterized by the highest densities of domestic ruminants. However, strong dependence between wild and domestic ruminant densities (ρS = −0.6; p < 0.0001), or their relation with the part of Poland (ρS = −0.5; p < 0.0001 and ρS = 0.6; p < 0.0001, respectively), or association between the part of country and the percent of forest area (ρS = 0.3; p < 0.0001) should be considered when interpreting those results. High geographic variation in SBV seroprevalence in wildlife was described also in France and Belgium ,. The differences may be related to the vector exposure of wild host species in relation to their habitat, vector abundance or population structure. In the Spanish study, SBV infection rate of roe deer inhabiting the lowlands was significantly higher than the low prevalence in Pyrenean chamois and mouflon residing in the high mountains of the same national park . Another factor determining the differences in SBV exposure may be connected to the species and size of the animal (age and body weight). In our study, SBV seroprevalence differed significantly between the species and body weight of wild ruminants, with European bison (81.9%) and the heaviest animals (42.4%) showing the highest seroprevalences (Table 1). It is consistent with the previous study which showed lower seroprevalences in smaller ruminants (sheep and goats) in respect to cattle . At this point, the limitation of the study should also be considered. Table 1 presents the results of the univariable analysis, however some variables such as wild and domestic ruminant densities, part of Poland and forest area were cross-correlated and therefore might influence the interpretation of the results. Despite the assumption of homogenous distribution of the different species in the country, one should be aware that sampling of large wildlife species is restricted by local regulations or practices which might affect the interpretation of statistical analysis. Whether the differences in SBV seropositivity are connected to the species susceptibility, the animal size or age is difficult to determine with certainty, especially as those characteristics are closely related. The differences of species susceptibility to SBV infection have been studied experimentally. Poskin et al.  and Wernike et al.  have shown that a lower infectious dose of SBV is required to infect cattle in comparison to sheep which would need ten times higher dose of the virus to get seroconversion in all inoculated animals. Therefore the higher seroprevalence in bison may reflect their higher susceptibility as in cattle. Another explanation might be the higher production of carbon dioxide in the larger ruminant species which is one of the strongest midge attractants and may promote higher exposure to their bites and hence to SBV infection. Studies on the feeding behavior confirm the observation. According to Lassen et al.  and Ayllón et al.  among others, most Culicoides species feed preferentially on cattle. In relation to high SBV infection rate in European bison, the specific environment of the tested population should also be considered important. The European bison included in the study originated from a reserve at the Białowieża Forest which is known for their vast marshes and therefore abundant in the midge vectors. The area is neighboring with Polish Eastern borders. Interestingly, the SBV prevalence in wild ruminants was increased in the Eastern part of the country which is known for higher density of cattle reared extensively in smaller size herds, often pastured enabling SBV transmission at the interface between domestic and wild ruminant populations . In contrast to Eastern Poland, the density of domestic ruminant population on the Western side of Vistula river is lower, while the population size of wild ungulates is significantly higher. Those observations suggest that SBV infection in wild ruminants is more likely to be the effect of spillover from domestic livestock and not the opposite. Probably, the environment characteristics such as humidity, temperature, variation in temperature during night and day affecting the presence and density of vector influence the possible transmission and consequently the prevalence in both domestic and wild animals. Perhaps the role of SBV wildlife reservoirs threatening domestic ruminants should not be overemphasized . In case of endangered and protected species such as European bison, the threat to the reproduction and health of the animals should not be underestimated. A single clinical case connected to SBV infection have been already described in an elk calf in Poland, however the association could not be proven . Species susceptibility should be investigated further.
In order to estimate the risk factors of SBV infection in wild ruminants in Poland, the associations between SBV seropositivity and animal-level variables were tested by multivariable mixed-effects logistic regression model. The final model which included four risk factors for SBV infection and species as fixed effect was developed for the wild ruminants in Poland (Table 2). The collinear variables were excluded. The odds of SBV seropositivity were significantly higher for the animals which were reared in captivity (OR = 3.2, p = 0.004) in respect to free-ranging animals. Different environment characteristics could influence the epidemiological role of the different species as well as the biological behavior of free ranging animals. Different land use of free ranging could increase or reduce the contact with vectors. And again, already discussed and related risk factors for SBV infection: the origin from the Eastern part of the country and the higher densities of domestic ruminant population were found significant in the model. Interestingly, as already observed in the univariable analysis, SBV seroprevalence was associated with animal age also in the final model. The risk of SBV infection was ten times higher in older than 1 year animals in comparison to the younger ones. First of all, this association may again suggest the association to the size of the animal, however young wild animals are always in direct contact with adults, therefore the body dimension should not explain the different seroprevalences. Notwithstanding, decrease of seropositive young animals indicating smaller exposure of animals born in 2013 may imply the subside of SBV epidemic in Poland. Additionally, passive immunity should be considered important when estimating the true prevalence in the youngest animals. Recent study of Elbers et al.  have shown the decay of maternal antibodies in calves 5–6 months after their birth, however the decline of passive immunity can vary depending individual species of wild ruminants and it may proceed at a different pace than in cattle. The animals below one year of age belonged to all the species included in the study and originated from five different hunting districts spread evenly across the country. Ten out of 41 youngest animals were equal or below 6 months of age. The single SBV seropositive one among them was 6-months-old European bison from Białowieża Primeval Forest, located at the extreme east of Poland.
Wild ruminants might play a role in SBV transmission in Poland, however lower seroprevalence in relation to the domestic ruminants suggests the spill-over effect from the latter, rather than inverse. The higher SBV seroprevalence in the Eastern part of the country suggests eastbound transmission of SBV in Europe, while low SBV prevalence in the wild ruminants below one year old may indicate possible decline of SBV epidemic in Poland. The species and size of the ruminant seem to be significant risk factors for SBV infection, probably due to the different species susceptibility and/or increased attraction of midges to larger animals.
Hoffmann B, Scheuch M, Höper D, Jungblut R, Holsteg M, Schirrmeier H, Eschbaumer M, Goller KV, Wernike K, Fischer M, Breithaupt A, Mettenleiter TC, Beer M: Novel orthobunyavirus in Cattle, Europe, 2011. Emerg Infect Dis. 2012, 18: 469-472. 10.3201/eid1803.111905. doi:10.3201/eid1803.111905
van den Brom R, Luttikholt SJ, Lievaart-Peterson K, Peperkamp NH, Mars MH, van der Poel WH, Vellema P: Epizootic of ovine congenital malformations associated with Schmallenberg virus infection. Tijdschr Diergeneeskd. 2012, 137: 106-111.
Tarlinton R, Daly J, Dunham S, Kydd JH: Schmallenberg virus: could wildlife reservoirs threaten domestic livestock?. Vet J. 2013, 198: 309-10. doi:10.1016/j.tvjl.2013.10.003
Larska M, Krzysiak M, Smreczak M, Polak MP, Żmudziński JF: First detection of Schmallenberg virus in elk (Alces alces) indicating infection of wildlife in Białowieża National Park in Poland. Vet J. 2013, 198: 279-81. doi:10.1016/j.tvjl.2013.08.013
General Directorate of National Forest Holding: The summary of the hunting plans for 2013/2014. National Forestry Database (SILP), 2014.
Central Statistical Office: Forestry. Warsaw 2013.
Ministry of Environment: Regulation on the detailed conditions for the performing hunting and marking carcasses (Dz.U. z 2005 Nr 61 poz. 548). Warsaw, 2005.
Krzysiak M, Larska M: Pharmacological immobilization of European bison (Bison bonasus). Medycyna Wet. 2014, 70: 172-175.
Polish General Directorate for Environmental Protection: Regulations DOP-OZGIZ.6401.06.7.2012.1 s and DOPOZ. 6401.06.7.2012.1 s1.Warsaw, 2012.
Central Statistical Office [http://www.stat.gov.pl/gus]
Casaubon J, Chaignat V, Vogt HR, Michel AO, Thür B, Ryser-Degiorgis MP: Survey of bluetongue virus infection in free-ranging wild ruminants in Switzerland. BMC Vet Res. 2013, 9: 166. doi:10.1186/1746-6148-9-166
Barlow A, Green P, Banham T, Healy N: Serological confirmation of SBV infection in wild British deer. Vet Rec. 2013, 172: 429. doi:10.1136/vr.f2438
Chiari M, Sozzi E, Zanoni M, Alborali LG, Lavazza A, Cordioli P: Serosurvey for schmallenberg virus in alpine wild ungulates. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2014, 61: 1-3. doi:10.1111/tbed.12158
Fernández-Aguilar X, Pujols J, Velarde R, Rosell R, López-Olvera JR, Marco I, Pumarola M, Segalés J, Lavín S, Cabezón O: Schmallenberg virus circulation in high mountain ecosystem, Spain. Emerg Infect Dis. 2014, 20: 1062-4. doi:10.3201/eid2006.130961
Laloy E, Bréard E, Sailleau C, Viarouge C, Desprat A, Zientara S, Klein F, Hars J, Rossi S: Schmallenberg virus infection among red deer, France, 2010–2012. Emerg Infect Dis. 2014, 20: 131-4. doi:10.3201/eid2001.130411
Linden A, Desmecht D, Volpe R, Wirtgen M, Gregoire F, Pirson J, Paternostre J, Kleijnen D, Schirrmeier H, Beer M, Garigliany MM: Epizootic spread of Schmallenberg virus among wild cervids, Belgium, Fall 2011. Emerg Infect Dis. 2012, 18: 2006-8. doi:10.3201/eid1812.121067
Kaba J, Czopowicz M, Witkowski L: Schmallenberg virus antibodies detected in Poland. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2013, 60: 1-3. doi:10.1111/tbed.12039
Larska M, Polak MP, Grochowska M, Lechowski L, Związek JS, Żmudziński JF: First report of Schmallenberg virus infection in cattle and midges in Poland. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2013, 60: 97-101. doi:10.1111/tbed.12057
Larska M, Kęsik-Maliszewska J, Kuta A: Spread of Schmallenberg virus infections in the ruminants in Poland between 2012 and 2013. Bull Vet Inst Pulawy. 2014, 58: 169-176. doi:10.2478/bvip-2014-0026
Poskin A, Martinelle L, Mostin L, Van Campe W, Dal Pozzo F, Saegerman C, Cay AB, De Regge N: Dose-dependent effect of experimental Schmallenberg virus infection in sheep. Vet J. 2014, 201: 419-22. doi:10.1016/j.tvjl.2014.05.031
Wernike K, Eschbaumer M, Breithaupt A, Hoffmann B, Beer M: Schmallenberg virus challenge models in cattle: infectious serum or culture-grown virus?. Vet Res. 2012, 43: 84. doi:10.1186/1297-9716-43-84
Lassen SB, Nielsen SA, Kristensen M: Identity and diversity of blood meal hosts of biting midges (Diptera: Ceratopogonidae: Culicoides Latreille) in Denmark. Parasit Vectors. 2012, 5: 1-9. doi:10.1186/1756-3305-5-143
Ayllón T, Nijhof AM, Weiher W, Bauer B, Allène X, Clausen PH: Feeding behaviour of Culicoides spp. (Diptera: Ceratopogonidae) on cattle and sheep in northeast Germany. Parasit Vectors. 2014, 7: 34. doi:10.1186/1756-3305-7-34
Elbers AR, Stockhofe-Zurwieden N, van der Poel WH: Schmallenberg virus antibody persistence in adult cattle after natural infection and decay of maternal antibodies in calves. BMC Vet Res. 2014, 10: 103. doi:10.1186/1746-6148-10-103
This work was supported by NCBiR projects: 208020 and NR12-0126-10. The authors thank Agnieszka Nowakowska, Maria Sudowska, and Karol Stasiak for their technical assistance, Artur Jabłoński for the coordination of animal sampling. We are grateful to Magdalena Konsencjusz-Białowąs and Jan Błaszczyk from General Directorate of National Forest Holding for providing current data on population of free-living animals in Poland.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
ML: design of the study, lab work and manuscript preparation; MKK: concept development, sampling, data collection, results discussion, manuscript revisions; JKM: lab work, database preparation, statistical analysis, manuscript preparation; JR: sampling, data collection, results discussion, manuscript review. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.