- Research article
- Open Access
Pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA genes in fecal samples reveals high diversity of hindgut microflora in horses and potential links to chronic laminitis
BMC Veterinary Research volume 8, Article number: 231 (2012)
The nutrition and health of horses is closely tied to their gastrointestinal microflora. Gut bacteria break down plant structural carbohydrates and produce volatile fatty acids, which are a major source of energy for horses. Bacterial communities are also essential for maintaining gut homeostasis and have been hypothesized to contribute to various diseases including laminitis. We performed pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA bacterial genes isolated from fecal material to characterize hindgut bacterial communities in healthy horses and those with chronic laminitis.
Fecal samples were collected from 10 normal horses and 8 horses with chronic laminitis. Genomic DNA was extracted and the V4-V5 segment of the 16S rRNA gene was PCR amplified and sequenced on the 454 platform generating a mean of 2,425 reads per sample after quality trimming. The bacterial communities were dominated by Firmicutes (69.21% control, 56.72% laminitis) and Verrucomicrobia (18.13% control, 27.63% laminitis), followed by Bacteroidetes, Proteobacteria, and Spirochaetes. We observed more OTUs per individual in the laminitis group than the control group (419.6 and 355.2, respectively, P = 0.019) along with a difference in the abundance of two unassigned Clostridiales genera (P = 0.03 and P = 0.01). The most abundant bacteria were Streptococcus spp., Clostridium spp., and Treponema spp.; along with unassigned genera from Subdivision 5 of Verrucomicrobia, Ruminococcaceae, and Clostridiaceae, which together constituted ~ 80% of all OTUs. There was a high level of individual variation across all taxonomic ranks.
Our exploration of the equine fecal microflora revealed higher bacterial diversity in horses with chronic laminitis and identification of two Clostridiales genera that differed in abundance from control horses. There was large individual variation in bacterial communities that was not explained in our study. The core hindgut microflora was dominated by Streptococcus spp., several cellulytic genera, and a large proportion of uncharacterized OTUs that warrant further investigation regarding their function. Our data provide a foundation for future investigations of hindgut bacterial factors that may influence the development and progression of chronic laminitis.
The microflora within the gastrointestinal system directly affects energy metabolism, digestive function, mucosal immune system development, and disease pathogenesis of its eukaryotic host [1–4]. This is particularly true for herbivores, including the horse, which are dependent upon fermentation by bacteria to utilize plant structural carbohydrates . Therefore, a detailed knowledge of gut microflora is essential for understanding the nutritional needs of horses and the contribution of gut homeostasis to equine health. Research on bacterial communities has recently flourished with the application of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology . Studies incorporating NGS have led to the discovery of thousands of novel species (i.e., Operational Taxonomic Units [OTUs]) and elucidation of their ecological function within the gut of vertebrates [5–7]. Numerous factors including the evolutionary history of the host, age, and diet influence the diversity of gut microbes; they in turn have been implicated in a broad range of disorders including Crohn’s disease, chronic diarrhea, inflammatory bowel disease, type I diabetes, obesity, and asthma [2, 7–9].
Alterations in hindgut bacterial communities have also been associated with several equine diseases [10–17]. Excess nonstructural carbohydrates (i.e., starches, fructans, or simple sugars) that are not digested in the foregut enter the cecum and colon, where bacterial fermentation produces byproducts including lactic acid and gas, which can cause colic [4, 16, 17]. The same initiators can also lead to the development of laminitis, which often occurs subsequent to overconsumption of grain or after feeding on lush pasture rich with nonstructural carbohydrates [18–20]. Starch and oligofructose overload-induced models have revealed strong associations between onset of laminitis and proliferation of Streptococcus and Lactobacillus bacteria, with a concurrent decrease in intraluminal pH [12–15, 21–23].
Numerous studies have characterized and enumerated bacteria of the equine hindgut, primarily relying on culturing of bacteria, clone-based sequencing of Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) amplicons, denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), or gene terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP) [21, 23–32]. The primary microbes detected consisted of Gram-positive bacteria, many of which were associated with the cluster XIVa of Clostridiaceae, Streptococcus spp., and Lactobacillus spp. [14, 22, 24, 26]. Up to 96% of all observed OTUs could not be assigned, highlighting how little was known about this ecosystem .
Recently researchers have begun to apply 454 sequencing of 16S rRNA amplicons to understand the equine gut microflora [10, 33, 34]. A total of 1,518 OTUs have been observed in feces from just two horses, with Firmicutes, Verrucomicrobia, and Proteobacteria being the most abundant Phyla, and Subdivision 5 Incertae sedis spp., TM7 Incertae sedis spp., and Treponema spp. the most common genera . In a study examining colitis, Firmicutes were found to dominate the feces of normal horses in contrast to Bacteroidetes in horses with undifferentiated colitis . Bacterial communities in the stomach were also found to be dominated by the Phyla Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, and Bacteroidetes, with Lactobacillus spp., Streptococcus spp., and Moraxella spp. comprising the most abundant genera . The stomach microflora segregated based on management (stabled versus pastured) and sampling methods (biopsy versus post mortem) . These studies show a much more diverse assembly of bacteria than previously described; however, the mechanisms linking bacterial diversity to diseases such as colic, colitis, and laminitis are yet to be elucidated.
We thus explored the equine hindgut microflora by pyrosequencing bacterial 16S rRNA gene segments present in feces of normal horses and those suffering from chronic laminitis. Our goals were to (1) describe the level of microbial diversity and (2) compare the microflora of healthy horses to those with chronic laminitis. We hypothesized that horses with chronic laminitis, which had in the past experienced a bout of acute laminitis and presumably a radical shift in bacterial flora that accompanies this disease, would harbor a different microbial population. Our study contributes to the characterization of the equine gut microbiome and its potential link to laminitis.
Sequencing depth and alpha diversity
The mean number of reads per sample was 5,159 (range 1,173 – 33,204). When we removed two outliers with the highest depth (12,113 and 30,911 reads) the mean dropped to 2,425 (range 1,032 – 6,578). The 16S rRNA sequences were deposited in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive under the Metagenome BioProject PRJNA177883. One of the horses was a pony and another had recently been on antibiotics so these were not included in the study groups. We separated the horses into 2 groups; those that did not have any history of laminitis (control, n = 9) and those that had chronic laminitis (laminitis, n = 7). We detected a total of 4,894 OTUs in fecal samples from all horses. Of these, 34% (1,660) were identified as chimeras by DECIPHER and excluded from downstream analysis leaving 3,234 OTUs . After the chimeras were removed the mean sequences per sample dropped to 2,204. The laminitis group had a greater number of OTUs per horse than the control group (mean = 419.6 versus 355.2, respectively, P = 0.019) (Table 1). The rarefaction curve of observed OTUs did not plateau with increasing reads suggesting that a higher number of reads per sample would have provided a more comprehensive catalog of bacterial taxa (Figure 1A). However, the Chao1 index of bacterial richness did start to plateau at ~600 reads indicating that the main components of community diversity were detected with our level of depth (Figure 1B). The Chao1 was significantly different between control and laminitis groups (P = 0.020) (Table 1).
The majority of OTUs belonged to Firmicutes (69.21% control, 56.72% laminitis) (Figure 2A). Verrucomicrobia was next most abundant (18.13% control, 27.63% laminitis) followed by Bacteroidetes (5.71% control, 9.94% laminitis). The remaining 6.95% of the equine bacterial population was either Spirochaetes (2.52%), Proteobacteria (0.95%), or belonged to one of 11 other Phyla (0.13%). Firmicutes was always the most abundant. Verrucomicrobia was the second most abundant in all of the horses, except for the pony and the horse that had received antibiotics within the last 2 weeks. In both these animals, Proteobacteria was the second most abundant Phylum.
Twenty-nine bacterial Classes were observed in horse feces; only 8 of these contained >1% of all OTUs. Clostridia of the Firmicutes Phylum was the most abundant (41.75% control, 38.15% laminitis) (Figure 2B). In the controls, the second most numerous was Bacilli (26.65%), also in Firmicutes, and third was Subdivision 5 of Verrucomicrobia (Verruco-5) (16.81%); however, this trend was reversed in the laminitis group (17.44% Bacilli and 25.02% Verruco-5). In all but one horse, either Bacilli or Clostridia were the most common. However, large individual variation in abundance was observed; Bacilli varied from 1.11% to 93.57%, Clostridia from 2.22% to 47.42%, and Verruco-5 from 0.86% to 38.19%.
A total of 44 Orders were detected, however, 82% of all OTUs belonged to only 3 of them; Clostridiales (41.63% control, 37.99% laminitis), Lactobacillales (25.10% control, 16.86% laminitis), and RFP12 of Verruco-5 (16.79% control, 25.02% laminitis) (Figure 2C). Additional Orders with a frequency greater than 1% included Bacteroidales, Spirochaetales, Bacillales, and Verrucomicrobiales. The most common among individuals was either Lactobacillales (in 4 control and 3 laminitis horses) or Clostridiales (in 6 control and 4 laminitis horses). There were large amounts of individual variation in abundance of Orders (e.g., Lactobacillales ranging from 3.18% to 93.53%). The Order Burkholderiales of Proteobacteria was the third most common in the pony (14.64%), yet it was observed in only two other horses at a low frequency (< 0.05%).
Eighty-two Families were detected among all horses with the most dominant being Streptococcaceae (24.17% control, 16.11% laminitis), followed by an unassigned Family in the RFP12 Order of Verrucomicrobia (16.79% control, 25.02% laminitis), and Ruminococcaceae (13.15% control, 14.40% laminitis) (Figure 2D). Additional abundant Families included Clostridiaceae, Lachnospiraceae, unassigned Bacteroidales, 2 unassigned Clostridiales, Spirochaetaceae, Verrucomicrobiaceae, and Clostridiales Family XIII Incertae sedi. Ninety percent of all OTUs where attributed to these 9 Families. There were also large amounts of individual variation at this taxonomic level, with the abundance of the unassigned RFP12 Family ranging from 1.1% to 38.19% and Streptococcaceae from 0.40% to 74.99%. Only 0.80% of all reads were attributed to Lactobacillaceae.
A total of 108 genera were identified among the 18 sampled horses, with an average of 53.4 ± 1.60 SE per horse. Nineteen genera were found in > 87% of horses; of these 11 were not assigned to any previously described genus (Table 2). Majority of the genera were observed in only a few of the horses. Eighty-nine were present in less than 20% of the individuals and 58 were detected in only one animal.
The dominant genera were Streptococcus (21.00% control, 16.03% laminitis), an unassigned genus in the RFP12 Order of Verruco-5 (16.79% control, 25.02% laminitis), and an unassigned genus in the Ruminococcaceae family (8.30% control, 9.99% laminitis) (Table 2, Figure 2E). Streptococcus was the most abundant genus in 6 control horses and 3 laminitic horses, while the RFP12 genus dominated most of the other horses. Differences in abundance for the top three genera between control and laminitis groups were not significant (P > 0.21). Twelve of the 20 most abundant genera were unassigned. Among the classified dominant genera were Strepococcus, Clostridium, Treponema, Akkermansia, Oscillospira, Ruminococcus, Lactobacillus, Staphylococcus, and Coprococcus. There were significantly more OTUs attributed to two unassigned Clostridiales genera in the laminitis group compared to the control (P = 0.03 and P = 0.01) (Table 2). Similar to all other levels of classification, there was large individual variation in the abundance of the dominant genera; for example, Streptococcus varied from 0.40% to 91.96%, the RFP12 genus from 2.78% to 32.60%, and the Ruminococcaceae genus from 0.36% to 15.72%.
The short 16S sequences (< 500 bp) generated during this study did not permit reliable species-level assignments. Nonetheless, we examined OTUs with greater than 1% abundance to determine which described species they are most closely related to. We detected the following taxa: Streptococcus equinus serotype 3, Rhodococcus wratislaviensis oucz59, Prevotella ruminicola, Clostridium sardiniense, Williamsia muralis, Clostridium chartatabidum, Clostridium orbiscindens. Clostridium had the highest number of species relative to other genera (33).
Statistical tests dependent on taxonomic categories often fail to detect community level differences in diversity . Approaches that are independent of OTU assignments have thus been developed for comparing microbiomes . We tested the control and laminitis groups for community shifts in the microflora using UniFrac distance, which compares the phylogenetic diversity within groups and is independent of taxonomic classification . To visualize the differences between groups we conducted Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA) of weighted and unweighted UniFrac distances and plotted the 3 factors that explained the greatest portion of variation. Jacknifed weighted and unweighted UniFrac distances did not show any significant differences between the two groups (Figure 3A,B,C).
We observed more unique OTUs (3,234) than detected by Shepherd et al.  (1,510 OTUs) despite our lower read depth (2,204 versus 28,458, respectively). This is likely because we had a greater number of horses (16 versus 2). However, our Chao1 index of bacterial richness (795.7) and Shannon Index of bacterial diversity (5.07) were lower than in the previous study (2,359 and 6.7, respectively) . There was significantly higher bacterial diversity as estimated from OTUs and the Chao1 index in the laminitis group compared to the control (P = 0.019, P = 0.020, respectively). The only other significant differences between the control and laminitis groups was the higher abundance of two undescribed genera of Clostridiales in the laminitis horses (P = 0.03 and P = 0.01, respectively). This suggests potential changes in bacterial communities that should be further explored.
Our lower bacterial richness and diversity relative to what was previously reported could be attributed to an insufficient number of reads to capture all of the diversity within each sample, particularly for the low abundance OTUs . This is supported by our OTU rarefaction plot that fails to plateau (Figure 1A). Future studies need to generate closer to the 5,000 reads per sample previously recommended . We targeted this level of depth; however, because one of our samples was over-represented (30,911) in the pooled multiplex of amplicons, it reduced the number of reads that were generated for the other samples. Therefore, greater attention needs to be given to DNA extraction, PCR amplification, and library construction so that each amplicon is equally represented.
We successfully assigned a greater number of reads to Phyla (98.42% versus < 62%) than several previous studies using 16S rRNA sequences [24, 33]. This is likely because they did not identify and exclude chimeras, which are known to inflate the number of unclassified OTUs . We detected the same number of Phyla (16) as in Shepherd et al., including 4 that were not previously observed in horses; MVP-15, Synergistetes, Chlamydiae, and Deferribacteres [10, 33]. The most abundant Phylum we observed in horses, Firmicutes, was also the major component of equine intestinal flora in previous studies that analyzed feces from two adult Arabian geldings  and 6 healthy horses , stomach contents from 9 hay-fed stabled horses , and more traditional studies that used clone-based Sanger sequencing [24, 31]. Firmicutes are also common in the gut of other diverse taxa, from cats, dogs, and polar bears to cattle [38–40]. In contrast, Bacteroidetes was the most abundant Phylum among horses that had colitis, supporting the hypothesis that Firmicutes play an important role in gut function .
Verrucomicrobia, Bacteroidetes, and Proteobacteria represented the next largest components of the equine gut microbiome that we observed; a pattern similar to previous studies, although the Phyla were not always in the same Order [10, 31, 33]. We detected higher levels of Verrucomicrobia than previously reported (21.78% versus < 5%) [10, 24]. The abundance of this Phylum in horses from central Texas suggests it plays a more important role in hindgut function than previously appreciated. Our second most abundant genus among all horses was an unknown type within the RFP12 Order of Verrucomicrobia. This is a good candidate for culturing in order to classify it and characterize this taxa’s metabolic function.
The cecum and colon of the horse are important for the breakdown of structural carbohydrates and production of volatile fatty acids . Therefore, we expected to detect bacteria known to play such a role, including Ruminococcus spp., Fibrobacter spp., Eubacterium spp., and Treponema spp. [24, 41]. We indeed detected all of the above; Ruminococcus had a mean of 1.03%, Fibrobacter 0.042%, Eubacterium 0.004%, and Treponema 2.18%. Our values were consistent with what has been previously observed (0.50% – 4.4%, 0.01% – 0.75%, 0.09%, 1.90% – 3.00%, respectively) [10, 24, 33, 41]. Interestingly, among the most abundant were unassigned genera of Ruminococcaceae that together composed 8.75% of all OTUs. These may represent important uncharacterized cellulytic bacteria and warrant further investigation.
A vast amount of individual variation was observed in horses at all taxonomic levels. A large portion of this likely came from environmental heterogeneity and differences in animal history, combined with lack of sequencing depth. However, similar individual variation in the equine gut microflora was previously observed. For example, in a study that had a mean of 4,712 reads per sample Bacteroidetes varied from 9.0% to 21.3% and Proteobacteria from 0.0% to 42.7% . Such large individual variation may be a natural trait of equine gut communities; however, the lack of detailed studies using a large number of horse samples limits the inferences that can be made from these patterns.
The genera previously found dominating the lower intestinal microflora in two Arabian geldings based on 16S rRNA pyrosequencing of fecal samples included Blautia spp., Fibrobacter spp., Subdivision 5 Incertae sedis spp., TM7 Incertae sedis spp., Treponema spp., and Ruminococcus spp. . In contrast, fecal analysis of a more diverse group of horses found the primary genera Clostridium spp., Coptotermes spp., Enterococcus spp., Fusobacterium spp., Porphyromonas spp., Pseudomonas spp., and Prevotella spp. . A study that used intestinal samples detected many unassigned genera affiliated with Clostridium spp., Butyrivibrio spp., Ruminococcus spp., and Eubacterium spp. . We detected all of the above except Coptotermes spp., Porphyromonas spp., and Pseudomonas spp.. Among the 14 genera that we observed with > 1.0% abundance were Streptococcus spp., Akkermansia spp., and Oscillospira spp., and 8 genera that could not be assigned to any described genus. This large proportion of unassigned genera among highly abundant OTUs highlights the need for more traditional studies characterizing bacteria and their phenotypic traits to better understand the function of the equine hindgut microflora.
Within abundant genera we found evidence suggesting additional diversity. The most diverse genus was Clostridium, which exhibits a wide range of functions and contains both beneficial and pathogenic representatives . For example, C. botulinum causes botulism as well as productivity problems and C. difficile leads to severe diarrhea and colitis in both humans and livestock [43, 44]. Yet, many Clostridium spp. are cellulytic and important for the digestion of plant material [45, 46]. We detected 33 species of Clostridium, including C. botulinum in one horse. The population dynamics of bacterial species and their interactions can influence normal gut function and the development of diseases . It is possible that some of the bacterial shifts that affect disease states such as laminitis occur at the species level.
There are numerous lines of evidence suggesting hindgut microflora play a role in the development of laminitis. Several studies have examined the bacterial response during various experimental laminitis models [12–14, 21–23]. An estimated 53% of acute laminitis cases occur after overconsumption of grain or grass rich with nonstructural carbohydrates (i.e., starch, fructans, or simple sugars) , which is also associated with an explosive proliferation of Streptococcus spp. and Lactobacillus spp. in the cecum and a concurrent decrease in the intraluminal pH [1, 12, 15]. Potentially, either of these may be a factor in laminitis. We found remarkable variation in Streptococcus spp. among healthy horses (0.40% to 91.96% of all OTUs); therefore the absolute abundance of Streptococcus spp. might not be important relative to other changes disrupting hindgut equilibrium.
In the carbohydrate overload model of laminitis, Garner et al.  found that Lactobacillus spp. increased in abundance by a factor of 105. These changes led to decreased intraluminal pH through the production of lactic acid, which caused death and lysis of other bacterial species including Enterobacteriaceae spp. and Bacilli spp. . Garner hypothesized that these release endotoxins and cause mucosal damage, contributing to the development of laminitis. Endotoxins can escape into the bloodstream and cause immune system activation, inflammation, fever, low blood pressure, and high respiration rate; some of these symptoms appear during the early stages of laminitis [47–49]. We found Lactobacillus spp. represented a small portion of the bacterial communities in the horses we sampled (0.82% controls, 0.60% laminitis). However, we only obtained samples from horses that had a previous history of this condition and not immediately after a relapse of laminitis. Therefore we would not have detected any previous transient Lactobacillus spp. proliferation. In addition, we sampled the microflora using feces, an approach which could potentially mask changes occurring in the stomach, cecum, and upper colon . The effects Lactobacillus spp. and Streptococcus spp. proliferation has on the equine gut microbiome following an increase in dietary nonstructural carbohydrates and relapse of chronic laminitis should be explored.
The composition of the hindgut microflora also has large impacts on feed digestibility and equine nutrition because the horse depends upon microbial fermentation to digest plant structural carbohydrates . Similar to previous studies we found that majority of the abundant bacterial genera were anaerobic fermenters, suggesting that the hindgut microflora are specialized for breaking down plant material. Alterations to bacterial communities may confer advantages to horses under certain dietary conditions . For example, gradual addition of grain into the diet increases the ratio of propionate to acetate, presumably by altering the bacterial microflora . Propionate can be directly converted to glucose and thus this shift is beneficial for horses with high energy needs . However, grain also has more simple sugars, which increase the risk of colic and laminitis [13, 17, 21]. Future studies should explore how bacterial diversity and function can mediate adaptation to high-energy diets and reduce disease risks.
Our exploration of the equine hindgut microflora revealed higher levels of bacterial diversity in horses with chronic laminitis and identification of two Clostridiales genera that differed in abundance from control horses. We observed large individual variation suggesting that bacterial populations may be influenced by factors such as genetic background, age, diet, feeding time, and body condition, which were not taken into account during this study. There was high abundance of cellulytic bacteria, primarily Ruminococcaceae and Clostridiaceae. We observed numerous abundant uncharacterized genera within Subdivision 5 of Verrucomicrobia, Clostridiales, and Ruminococcaceae that warrant further investigation into their function. Vast individual differences in Streptococcus abundance among healthy horses suggested that this genus is likely not closely linked with chronic laminitis. We recommend studies make efforts to reduce experimental variation by using more homogenous horse populations and incorporating rigorous normalization during 454 library construction to increase the sensitivity for biologically-relevant changes in bacterial communities.
Fresh fecal samples were collected from 10 healthy horses and 7 horses and 1 pony with chronic laminitis. One of the control horses had received antibiotics 2 weeks prior to sampling and therefore we did not include it in our control group. We also excluded the pony from the chronic laminitis group to reduce potential breed-specific differences. Horses were diagnosed as having chronic laminitis by a licensed veterinarian based on clinical presentation, case history, and radiographic evidence of dorsopalmar rotation of the distal phalanx. Horses were kept on two different farms in Brazos County, Texas. All horses had been resident at their respective farms for at least 6 months and had not experienced any recent changes in diet or housing conditions. All animals were maintained on a pelleted concentrate feed containing either 12% or 16% crude protein (Producer’s Co-op, Bryan, TX) in addition to coastal bermudagrass hay and limited amount of alfalfa hay. Detailed information about horses and concentrate feed composition may be found in Additional file 1: Tables S1 and S2. Horses were kept in stalls, large dry lots, or a combination of both. All horses had ad libitum access to water. Only naturally voided fecal samples were collected and therefore did not require an IACUC Animal Use Permit. A single sample was collected from each horse within 3 hours after the morning feeding. As feed takes approximately 28–46 hours to travel through the digestive tracks of horses, the microflora sampled from feces would not be influenced by feeding just prior to collection. Every attempt was made to collect samples immediately after defecation. After collection, samples were stored on wet ice for transport to the laboratory and frozen at −20°C.
DNA extraction and pyrosequencing
The DNA was extracted from feces using the phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol method after disrupting the starting material with bead beating as described in Suchodolski et al.. The V5-V9 region of 16S rRNA gene was pyrosequenced on the Roche 454 FLX-Titanium instrument (Roche Applied Science, Indianapolis, IN) by the Research and Testing Laboratory (Lubbock, TX) as previously described, with Titanium chemistry modifications [38, 53]. Briefly, a 570-bp segment of 16S rRNA was PCR amplified using the HotStarTaq Plus Master Mix Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA), 100 ng of template DNA, and universal Eubacterial primers that target majority of GI bacteria: 939 F-TTGACGGGGGCCCGCAC and 1492R-TACCTTGTTACGACTT [54, 55]. The exact span of the amplicon in relation to Streptococcus equinus strain ATCC 9812 16S rRNA complete sequence is 823 bp to 1409 bp (GenBank Accession NR_042052.1). The thermal conditions were 94°C denaturation for 3 min, 32 cycles of 94°C for 30 sec, 60°C for 40 sec, 72°C for 1 min, and a final 5-min elongation step at 72°C. Subsequently, a second PCR was performed on the above PCR products using the same conditions, but with modified fusing primers that had tag sequences added on the 5’ ends (i.e., LinkerA-Tags-939 F and LinkerB-1492R) to enable multiplexed 454 FLX amplicon pyrosequencing. This secondary PCR was used to incorporate tags and linkers into the 16S rRNA amplicons to avoid unbalanced amplification from the DNA samples. The final amplicons from different samples were mixed in equal volumes, purified using Agencourt AMPure XP beads (Agencourt Bioscience Corporation, Danvers), and sequenced on the 454 platform [38, 53].
Species-level operational taxonomic unit (OTU) assignments (>97% similarity, equal to number of matching nucleotides divided by the length of the shorter sequence ) were made after trimming positions with < Q25 quality score and discarding reads < 200 bp [56–58]. Sequences were depleted of chimeras and assignments to putative species (>97% similarity) were done with BlastN  against a manually curated database compiled from NCBI by the Research and Testing Laboratory (Lubbock, TX) . However, because species-level bacterial assignments using short, single-gene segments are not robust we only used this information to obtain an overview of the potential species present. The main comparisons of microbial diversity within and among horses were made for genus and higher-level classifications as described below.
The statistical analysis of alpha and beta diversity was done from taxonomic classifications and phylogenetic-based methods (UniFrac) not dependent on OTU assignments . The QIIME pipeline with standard scripts and default settings was used for taxa assignments (genus and higher), diversity estimates (OTUs, Chao1 index, phylogenetic distance index, Shannon index, and Simpson index), and phylogeny-based analyses using UniFrac [37, 59, 60]. Barcodes were removed and the reads trimmed of bases with quality score below Q25; reads with length < 200 bp or any ambiguous bases were removed from dataset. The remaining sequences were clustered using UCLUST with the furthest algorithm based on >97% similarity to define OTUs . Representative sequences were selected with the most abundant criteria. Chimeras were identified among the OTUs using DECIPHER and excluded from all subsequent analysis . Taxonomic assignments of the OTUs were made down to the genus level (>95% similarity) using the Ribosomal Database Project (RDP) classifier and the Greengenes reference core set “gg97_otus_4feb2011_aligned.fasta” available from http://greengenes.lbl.gov/cgi-bin/nph-index.cgi[61, 62]. Sequences were added to this reference alignment  with PyNAST and the alignment was optimized, then filtered to exclude sites with only gaps and excessively variable sites [62, 63]. A neighbor-joining phylogeny was reconstructed using FastTree for UniFrac analysis of beta diversity .
Rarefied OTU tables were generated to reduce sampling heterogeneity for observed OTUs and Chao1 index and tested for significant differences in QIIME. Unpaired t-tests were used to compare abundance of taxonomic groups between control and laminitis groups. Beta diversity was compared between control and laminitis groups using weighted and unweighted UniFrac phylogenetic-based distances. Principal Coordinate Analysis (PCoA) transformed the UniFrac distances into coordinates that explain the greatest amount of variation. The differences were visualized with 2D and 3D PCoA plots. To minimize sampling bias we rarified OTU matrices using the smallest number of reads observed in any one horse before conducting the UniFrac and PCoA analyses.
O'Hara AM, Shanahan F: The gut flora as a forgotten organ. Embo Reports. 2006, 7 (7): 688-693. 10.1038/sj.embor.7400731.
Neish AS: Microbes in Gastrointestinal Health and Disease. Gastroenterology. 2009, 136 (1): 65-80. 10.1053/j.gastro.2008.10.080.
Wardwell LH, Huttenhower C, Garrett WS: Current concepts of the intestinal microbiota and the pathogenesis of infection. Curr Infect Dis Rep. 2011, 13: 28-34. 10.1007/s11908-010-0147-7.
Hintz HF, Cymbaluk NF: Nutrition of the Horse. Ann Rev Nutr. 1994, 14: 243-267. 10.1146/annurev.nu.14.070194.001331.
MacLean D, Jones JDG, Studholme DJ: Application of 'next-generation' sequencing technologies to microbial genetics. Nature Rev Microbiol. 2009, 7 (4): 287-296.
Muegge BD, Kuczynski J, Knights D, Clemente JC, Gonzalez A, Fontana L, Henrissat B, Knight R, Gordon JI: Diet drives convergence in gut microbiome functions across mammalian phylogeny and within humans. Sci. 2011, 332 (6032): 970-974. 10.1126/science.1198719.
Turnbaugh PJ, Hamady M, Yatsunenko T, Cantarel BL, Duncan A, Ley RE, Sogin ML, Jones WJ, Roe BA, Affourtit JP, et al: A core gut microbiome in obese and lean twins. Nature. 2009, 457 (7228): 480-U487. 10.1038/nature07540.
Serino M, Luche E, Chabo C, Amar J, Burcelin R: Intestinal microflora and metabolic diseases. Diabetes Metab. 2009, 35 (4): 262-272. 10.1016/j.diabet.2009.03.003.
Suchodolski JS, Xenoulis PG, Paddock CG, Steiner JM, Jergens AE: Molecular analysis of the bacterial microbiota in duodenal biopsies from dogs with idiopathic inflammatory bowel disease. Vet Microbiol. 2010, 142 (3–4): 394-400.
Costa MC, Arroyo LG, Allen-Vercoe E, Stampfli HR, Kim PK, Sturgeon A, Weese JS: Comparison of the fecal microbiota of healthy horses and horses with colitis by high throughput sequencing of the V3-V5 region of the 16S rRNA gene. Plos One. 2012, 7 (41484): 1-11.
Garrett LA, Brown R, Poxton IR: A comparative study of the intestinal microbiota of healthy horses and those suffering from equine grass sickness. Vet Microbiol. 2002, 87 (1): 81-88. 10.1016/S0378-1135(02)00018-4.
Milinovich GJ, Trott DJ, Burrell PC, van Eps AW, Thoefner MB, Blackall LL, Al Jassim RAM, Morton JM, Pollitt CC: Changes in equine hindgut bacterial populations during oligofructose-induced laminitis. Environ Microbiol. 2006, 8 ((5): 885-898.
Milinovich GJ, Trott DJ, Burrell PC, Croser EL, Al Jassim RAM, Morton JM, van Eps AW, Pollitt CC: Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis of hindgut bacteria associated with the development of equine laminitis. Environ Microbiol. 2007, 9 (8): 2090-2100. 10.1111/j.1462-2920.2007.01327.x.
Milinovich GJ, Burrell PC, Pollitt CC, Klieve AV, Blackall LL, Ouwerkerk D, Woodland E, Trott DJ: Microbial ecology of the equine hindgut during oligofructose-induced laminitis. Isme Journal. 2008, 2 (11): 1089-1100. 10.1038/ismej.2008.67.
Garner HE, Coffman JR, Hahn AW, Hutcheson DP, Tumbleson ME: Equine laminitis of alimentary origin - experimental model. Am J Vet Res. 1975, 36 (4): 441-444.
Shirazi-Beechey SP: Molecular insights into dietary induced colic in the horse. Equine Vet J. 2008, 40 (4): 414-421. 10.2746/042516408X314075.
Durham AE: The role of nutrition in colic. Vet Clin North America-Equine Practice. 2009, 25 (1): 67-78. 10.1016/j.cveq.2008.11.003.
Geor RJ: Current Concepts on the Pathophysiology of Pasture-Associated Laminitis. Vet Clin North Am-Equine Pract. 2010, 26 (2): 265-276. 10.1016/j.cveq.2010.06.001.
Geor RJ: Pasture-associated laminitis. Vet Clin North America-Equine Practice. 2009, 25 (1): 39-50. 10.1016/j.cveq.2009.01.004.
USDA: Lameness & laminitis in U.S. horses. 2000, Fort Collins, Colorado: United States Department of Agriculture
Milinovich GJ, Klieve AV, Pollitt CC, Trott DJ: Microbial events in the hindgut during carbohydrate-induced equine laminitis. Vet Clin North America-Equine Practice. 2010, 26 (1): 79-94. 10.1016/j.cveq.2010.01.007.
Al Jassim RA, Scott PT, Trebbin AL, Trott D, Pollitt CC: The genetic diversity of lactic acid producing bacteria in the equine gastrointestinal tract. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2005, 248 (1): 75-81. 10.1016/j.femsle.2005.05.023.
Garner HE, Moore JN, Johnson JH, Clark L, Amend JF, Tritschler LG, Coffmann JR, Sprouse RF, Hutcheson DP, Salem CA: Changes in cecal flora associated with onset of laminitis. Equine Vet J. 1978, 10 (4): 249-252. 10.1111/j.2042-3306.1978.tb02273.x.
Daly K, Stewart CS, Flint HJ, Shirazi-Beechey SP: Bacterial diversity within the equine large intestine as revealed by molecular analysis of cloned 16S rRNA genes. FEMS Microbiol Ecol. 2001, 38 (2–3): 141-151.
Gronvold AMR, L'Abee-Lund TM, Strand E, Sorum H, Yannarell AC, Mackie RI: Fecal microbiota of horses in the clinical setting: Potential effects of penicillin and general anesthesia. Vet Microbiol. 2010, 145 (3–4): 366-372.
Morita H, Nakano A, Shimazu M, Toh H, Nakajima F, Nagayama M, Hisamatsu S, Kato Y, Takagi M, Takami H, et al: Lactobacillus hayakitensis, L-equigenerosi and L-equi, predominant lactobacilli in the intestinal flora of healthy thoroughbreds. Anim Sci J. 2009, 80 (3): 339-346. 10.1111/j.1740-0929.2009.00633.x.
Goodson J, Tyznik WJ, Cline JH, Dehority BA: Effects of an abrupt diet change from hay to concentrate on microbial numbers and physical-environment in the cecum of the pony. App Environ Microbiol. 1988, 54 (8): 1946-1950.
Julliand V, de Fombelle A, Drogoul C, Jacotot E: Feeding and microbial disorders in horses: Part 3 - Effects of three hay: grain ratios on microbial profile and activities. J Equine Vet Sci. 2001, 21 (11): 543-546. 10.1016/S0737-0806(01)70159-1.
Mackie RI, Wilkins CA: Enumeration of anaerobic bacterial microflora of the equine gastrointestinal tract. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1988, 54 (9): 2155-2160.
Willing B, Voros A, Roos S, Jones C, Jansson A, Lindberg JE: Changes in faecal bacteria associated with concentrate and forage-only diets fed to horses in training. Equine Vet J. 2009, 41 (9): 908-914. 10.2746/042516409X447806.
Yamano H, Koike S, Kobayashi Y, Hata H: Phylogenetic analysis of hindgut microbiota in Hokkaido native horses compared to light horses. Anim Sci J. 2008, 79 (2): 234-242. 10.1111/j.1740-0929.2008.00522.x.
Dougal K, Harris PA, Edwards A, Pachebat JA, Blackmore TM, Worgan WJ, Newbold CJ: A comparison of the microbiome and the metabolome of different regions of the equine hindgut. FEMS Microbiol Ecol. 2012, 1-12.
Shepherd ML, Swecker WS, Jensen RV, Ponder MA: Characterization of the fecal bacteria communities of forage-fed horses by pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA V4 gene amplicons. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2012, 326 (1): 62-68. 10.1111/j.1574-6968.2011.02434.x.
Perkins GA, den Bakker HC, Burton AJ, Erb HN, McDonough SP, McDonough PL, Parker J, Rosenthal RL, Wiedmann M, Dowd SE, et al: The equine stomach harbors 1 an abundant and diverse mucosal microbiota. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2012, 78: 2522-2531. 10.1128/AEM.06252-11.
Wright ES, Yilmaz LS, Noguera DR: DECIPHER, a search-based approach to chimera identification for 16S rRNA sequences. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2012, 78: 712-725.
Lozupone CA, Hamady M, Kelley ST, Knight R: Quantitative and qualitative beta diversity measures lead to different insights into factors that structure microbial communities. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2007, 73 (5): 1576-1585. 10.1128/AEM.01996-06.
Lozupone C, Lladser ME, Knights D, Stombaugh J, Knight R: UniFrac: an effective distance metric for microbial community comparison. Isme Journal. 2011, 5 (2): 169-172. 10.1038/ismej.2010.133.
Dowd SE, Callaway TR, Wolcott RD, Sun Y, McKeehan T, Hagevoort RG, Edrington TS: Evaluation of the bacterial diversity in the feces of cattle using 16S rDNA bacterial tag-encoded FLX amplicon pyrosequencing (bTEFAP). BMC Microbiol. 2008, 8 (125): 1-12.
Shanks OC, Kelty CA, Archibeque S, Jenkins M, Newton RJ, McLellan SL, Huse SM, Sogin ML: Community Structures of Fecal Bacteria in Cattle from Different Animal Feeding Operations. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2011, 77 (9): 2992-3001. 10.1128/AEM.02988-10.
Ley RE, Hamady M, Lozupone C, Turnbaugh PJ, Ramey RR, Bircher JS, Schlegel ML, Tucker TA, Schrenzel MD, Knight R, et al: Evolution of mammals and their gut microbes. Sci. 2008, 320 (5883): 1647-1651. 10.1126/science.1155725.
Julliand V, de Vaux A, Millet L, Fonty G: Identification of Ruminococcus flavefaciens as the predominant cellulolytic bacterial species of the equine cecum. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1999, 65: 3758-3741.
DuPont AW, DuPont HL: The intestinal microbiota and chronic disorders of the gut. Nature Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2011, 8 (9): 523-531. 10.1038/nrgastro.2011.133.
Sinh P, Barrett TA, Yun L: Clostridium difficile Infection and Inflammatory Bowel Disease: A Review. Gastroenterol Res Pract. 2011, 136064: 1-11.
Musa S, Moran C, Rahman T: Clostridium difficile infection and liver disease. J Gastrointestinal and Liver Dis. 2010, 19 (3): 303-310.
Songer JG: Clostridial diseases of small ruminants. Vet Res. 1998, 29 (3–4): 219-232.
Widyastuti Y, Lee WK, Suzuki K, Mitsuoka T: Isolation and characterization of rice-straw degrading clostridia from cattle rumen. J Vet Med Sci. 1992, 54 (1): 185-188. 10.1292/jvms.54.185.
Santos AS, Rodrigues MAM, Bessa RJB, Ferreira LM, Martin-Rosset W: Understanding the equine cecum-colon ecosystem: current knowledge and future perspectives. Animal. 2011, 5 (1): 48-56. 10.1017/S1751731110001588.
Werners AH, Bull S, Fink-Gremmels J: Endotoxaemia: a review with implications for the horse. Equine Vet J. 2005, 37 (4): 371-383.
Opal SM: Endotoxins and Other Sepsis Triggers. Endoxemia and Endotoxin Shock: Disease, Diagnosis and Therapy. Volume 167, edn. Edited by: Ronco C, Piccinni P, Rosner MH. 2010, 14-24.
Costa CC, Weese J: The equine intestinal microbiome. Ani Health Res Rev. 2012, 13: 121-128. 10.1017/S1466252312000035.
Hintz HF, Argenzio RA, Schryver HF: Digestion coefficients, blood glucose levels and molar percentage of volatile acids in intestinal fluid of ponies fed varying forage-grain ratios. J Anim Sci. 1971, 33 (5): 992-995.
Suchodolski JS, Ruaux CG, Steiner JM, Fetz K, Williams DA: Application of molecular fingerprinting for qualitative assessment of small-intestinal bacterial diversity in dogs. J Clin Microbiol. 2004, 42 (10): 4702-4708. 10.1128/JCM.42.10.4702-4708.2004.
Dowd SF, Sun Y, Wolcott RD, Domingo A, Carroll JA: Bacterial tag-encoded FLX amplicon pyrosequencing (bTEFAP) for microbiome studies: Bacterial diversity in the ileum of newly weaned Salmonella-infected pigs. Foodborne Pathogens and Disease. 2008, 5 (4): 459-472. 10.1089/fpd.2008.0107.
Rudi K, Skulberg OM, Larsen F, Jakobsen KS: Strain characterization and classification of oxyphotobacteria in clone cultures on the basis of 165 rRNA sequences from the variable regions V6, V7, and V8. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1997, 63 (7): 2593-2599.
Baker GC, Smith JJ, Cowan DA: Review and re-analysis of domain-specific 16S primers. J Microbiol Methods. 2003, 55 (3): 541-555. 10.1016/j.mimet.2003.08.009.
Edgar RC: Extreme high-speed clustering, alignment and database search. 2010, 1: 579-
Gontcharova V, Youn E, Wolcott RD, Hollister EB, Gentry TJ, Dowd SE: Black box chimera check (B2C2): a windows-based software for batch depletion of chimeras from bacterial 16S rRNA gene datasets. The Open Microbiology Journal. 2010, 4: 47-52. 10.2174/1874285801004010047.
Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ: Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol. 1990, 215 (3): 403-410.
Caporaso JG, Kuczynski J, Stombaugh J, Bittinger K, Bushman FD, Costello EK, Fierer N, Pena AG, Goodrich JK, Gordon JI, et al: QIIME allows analysis of high-throughput community sequencing data. Nature Methods. 2010, 7 (5): 335-336. 10.1038/nmeth.f.303.
Chao A, Bunge J: Estimating the number of species in a Stochastic abundance model. Biometrics. 2002, 58 (3): 531-539. 10.1111/j.0006-341X.2002.00531.x.
Wang Q, Garrity GM, Tiedje JM, Cole JR: Naive Bayesian classifier for rapid assignment of rRNA sequences into the new bacterial taxonomy. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2007, 73 (16): 5261-5267. 10.1128/AEM.00062-07.
McDonald D, Price MN, Goodrich J, Nawrocki EP, DeSantis TZ, Probst A, Andersen GL, Knight R, Hugenholtz P: An improved Greengenes taxonomy with explicit ranks for ecological and evolutionary analyses of bacteria and archaea. Isme J. 2012, 6 (3): 610-618. 10.1038/ismej.2011.139.
Caporaso JG, Bittinger K, Bushman FD, DeSantis TZ, Andersen GL, Knight R: PyNAST: a flexible tool for aligning sequences to a template alignment. Bioinforma. 2010, 26 (2): 266-267. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btp636.
Price MN, Dehal PS, Arkin AP: FastTree: Computing large minimum evolution trees with profiles instead of a distance matrix. Mol Biol Evol. 2009, 26 (7): 1641-1650. 10.1093/molbev/msp077.
Henneke DR, Potter GD, Kreider JL, Yeates BF: Relationship between condition score, physical measurements and body fat percentage in mares. Equine Vet J. 1983, 15: 371-372. 10.1111/j.2042-3306.1983.tb01826.x.
The authors wish to thank Dr. David Hood of the Hoof Diagnostic and Rehabilitation Clinic for providing access to samples. The study described herein was supported by funds from the United States Department of Agriculture (award # 2011-67012-30685 to SMS and 2010-65205-20446 to BPC) and the LINK Endowment.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
SMS collected samples, performed some of the data analysis, and drafted manuscript. BPC assisted in experimental design, data interpretation, and manuscript preparation. SD performed PCR amplification, pyrosequencing, and data analysis. JS performed DNA extractions and contributed to development of project. JEJ developed project, performed data analysis, and drafted manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: Table S1. Description of horses in each study group. The exact age of all horses in the laminitis group was not known; one horse was estimated to be 7 years of age, the others were over 15 years. None of the horses with laminitis exhibited signs of Cushing’s syndrome, although the initial cause of laminitis was not known for all animals. Abbreviations are as follows: BCS – body condition score , QH – Quarter horse, WB – Warmblood, TB – Thoroughbred. Table S2 Feed analysis. Comparison of guaranteed feed analysis of 12% concentrate pellets and 16% concentrate pellets used in this study. Pellets were formulated by Producer’s Co-op (Bryan, TX) and further information is available online: http://www.producerscooperative.com/productsservices/feednutrition/feeds/horse. (DOC 51 KB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0 ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Steelman, S.M., Chowdhary, B.P., Dowd, S. et al. Pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA genes in fecal samples reveals high diversity of hindgut microflora in horses and potential links to chronic laminitis. BMC Vet Res 8, 231 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1746-6148-8-231
- Bacterial Community
- Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism
- Nonstructural Carbohydrate
- Healthy Horse