- Research article
- Open Access
Drug quality analysis of isometamidium chloride hydrochloride and diminazene diaceturate used for the treatment of African animal trypanosomosis in West Africa
BMC Veterinary Researchvolume 14, Article number: 361 (2018)
Diminazene diaceturate (DA) and isometamidium chloride hydrochloride (ISM) are with homidium bromide, the main molecules used to treat African Animal Trypanosomosis (AAT). These drugs can be purchased from official suppliers but also from unofficial sources like local food markets or street vendors. The sub-standard quality of some of these trypanocides is jeopardizing the efficacy of treatment of sick livestock, leading thus to economic losses for the low-resource farmers and is contributing to the emergence and spread of drug resistance. The objective of this study was to assess the quality of trypanocidal drugs sold in French speaking countries of West Africa. In total, 308 drug samples including 282 of DA and 26 of ISM were purchased from official and unofficial sources in Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d’Ivoire, Mali, Niger and Togo. All samples were analysed at LACOMEV (Dakar, Senegal), a reference laboratory of the World Organisation for Animal Health, by galenic inspection and high performance liquid chromatography.
The results showed that 51.90% of the samples were non-compliant compared to the standards and were containing lower quantity of the active ingredient compared to the indications on the packaging. The non-compliances ranged from 63.27% in Togo to 32.65% in Burkina Faso (61.82% in Benin, 53.84% in Mali, 50% in Côte d’Ivoire, 47.36% in Niger). The rates of non-compliance were not statistically different (P = 0.572) from official or unofficial suppliers and ranged from 30 to 75% and from 0 to 65% respectively. However, the non-compliance was significantly higher for ISM compared to DA (P = 0.028).
The high non-compliance revealed in this study compromises the efficacy of therapeutic strategies against AAT, and is likely to exacerbate chemoresistance in West Africa. Corrective actions against sub-standard trypanocides urgently need to be taken by policy makers and control authorities.
In the 8 member countries of the “Union Economique et Monétaire Ouest Africaine” (UEMOA) (i.e. Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d’Ivoire, Mali, Niger, Senegal, Togo, Guinea Bissau), livestock breeding and agriculture represent 30% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and provide employment for 50% of the active population . In particular, the livestock sector plays a key role in the economies of West African countries by providing 44% of the agricultural GDP, which rises to 50% if the work force and organic fertilizer are included . In this context, reducing the constraints to agriculture that are posed by endemic animal diseases such as African trypanosomosis is of paramount importance for achieving food security and an alleviation of the poverty [3,4,5]. Strategies for limiting the impacts of trypanosomosis on animal health should target the vector, the parasite and the hosts. An ambitious continental programme aims at the creation and progressive expansion of tsetse and trypanosomosis-free areas i.e. the African Union - Pan African Tsetse and Trypanosomosis Eradication Campaign (AU-PATTEC), whose implementation started in Ethiopia, Kenya, Uganda in East Africa and Mali, Ghana, Burkina Faso in West Africa [6, 7]. However, tsetse flies are still widespread in West Africa, including in Burkina Faso [8, 9] and Mali , and unfortunately, the development of a vaccine against trypanosomosis remains elusive [11,12,13]. Thus, the control of the disease, currently, is heavily reliant on chemotherapy and prophylaxis. Three main molecules of trypanocides existing on the markets are: isometamidium chloride (ISM), diminazene aceturate (DA) and homidium salts, which represent respectively 40%, 30% and 26% of the total trypanocidal drug market by value . However, homidium salts are no longer advisable since the discovery of their mutagenic effects .
Since the 90’s, the privatization and liberalization of the veterinary services led to a situation where veterinary drugs are more often supplied by untrained sellers and administered by the farmers or poorly experienced/trained extension workers [16, 17]. The sub-standard quality of drugs is frequently cited as one of the main factors contributing to the development and the spread of trypanocidal drug resistance . A reinforcement and harmonisation of the veterinary legislation started in 2006 in the UEMOA zone and resulted in the creation of a unique marketing authorisation . However, a recent study showed a high proportion of trypanocides of sub-standard quality purchased from both official and unofficial suppliers in Northern Togo .
The objective of this study was to assess the quality of trypanocidal drugs sold by official and unofficial suppliers in 6 French speaking countries (i.e. Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d’Ivoire, Mali, Niger, Togo), except for Ghana and Nigeria that form the 8 member countries of RESCAO (Réseau d’épidemiosurveillance de la chimiorésistance aux trypanocides et acaricides en Afrique de l’Ouest) .
The study was carried out in selected sites in Benin (5), Burkina Faso (7), Côte d’Ivoire (4), Mali (4), Niger (6) and Togo (4) (Fig. 1). In each country, samples were collected in the cotton-belt and pastoral areas characterized by an intense use of veterinary drugs [22, 23].
Field protocol for sample collection was designed and provided by the Laboratoire de contrôle des médicaments vétérinaires (LACOMEV), a reference laboratory of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE), based in Dakar (Senegal). For each analysis, 10 sachets of 2.36 g or 5 sachets of 23.6 g DA and 10 sachets of 125 mg or 5 sachets of 1 g ISM were collected. Drugs were purchased in 2013 from official and unofficial sources, sealed in plastic bags and uniquely identified. Information available on the packaging (expiry date, manufacture date, etc.) was recorded in a standardized form. All the samples were purchased in dry galenic form except one liquid DA sample.
A total of 308 samples (282 of DA and 26 of ISM) were purchased out of which 98 and 210 from official and unofficial sources, respectively (Table 1). These samples of trypanocidal drugs included 62 trade names from 9 producing countries (Belgium, China, England, France, Germany, Netherlands, India, Nigeria and Spain) for DA and 6 trade names from 2 countries (France and Netherlands) for ISM.
All samples collected from the field were stored away from heat and moisture at CIRDES (Centre International de Recherche-Développement sur l’Elevage en zone Subhumide) in Bobo-Dioulasso (Burkina Faso), then labelled and packaged before shipment to LACOMEV for subsequent analysis.
Trypanocide quality analysis
All the drugs collected were analysed at LACOMEV prior to the expiry date indicated on the packaging, except for 19 samples (16 DA and 3 ISM) which were expired. The quality was determined firstly by galenic test including pH measurement, the solubility of the DA liquid as well as solutions reconstituted from DA or ISM granules according to the manufacturer’s recommendations. Secondly, the active ingredient was identified and its concentration measured using high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The galenic inspection and HPLC were carried out according to the OIE’s monograph prepared by the consortium GALVmed/FAO/IAEA/IFAH  using reference samples. A pH between 4 and 7 was considered as compliant. The solubility of solutions (liquid or reconstituted) was visually assessed with the naked eye for the absence of solid particles.
For DA, a measured concentration within ±10% of the manufacturer’s label claim was considered as compliant according to the threshold applied by LACOMEV . For ISM, the following criteria according OIE monograph were used: (i) presence of the four isomers (I, II, III, IV), (ii) a proportion of isomer I (principal component) equal to or greater than 55%, (iii) a proportion of isomers II, III and IV was equal to or less than 40% and (iv) a proportion of the four isomers between 95 and 102% (Figs. 2 and 3).
All statistical analyses were performed with the JMP 11 software (SAS Institute Inc.). The chi2-test was used to compare the different proportions of non-compliance. A logistic regression model was built using country, source (official or not) and compound (DA or ISM) as explanatory variables to determine the factors involved in the non-compliance of the trypanocidal drugs. P-values (P) < 0.05 were considered significant.
Proportion of non-compliant samples by country
The 19 samples (16 DA and 3 ISM) which were expired, were not included in analysis. The galenic and the HPLC tests allowed defining the compliance or non-compliance status of the other samples. The overall proportion of non-compliance of these was 51.90%. The proportions differed between countries (P = 0.025), with the lowest in Burkina Faso (32.65%) and the highest in Togo (63.27%). The proportions of non-compliance by country are illustrated in Fig. 4.
Proportion of non-compliance by source
No significant difference in non-compliance between the two supply sources was identified (Fig. 5). In the unofficial market 53.03% of the samples were non-compliant, against the 49.45% in the legal market (P = 0.572). However, in Mali, the rate of non-compliance was significantly higher in samples from the unofficial market compared to the official ones (75% vs 44.44%, P = 0.0414). These rates were not significantly different in Benin (37.5% vs 65.96%, P = 0.1256), in Côte d’Ivoire (54.55% vs 48.57%, P = 0.7296), in Niger (50% vs 45%, P = 0.7579) and in Togo (64.71% vs 62.5%, P = 0.8788). In Burkina Faso, only 1 DA sample was collected from the official market and found to be compliant by LACOMEV, whereas 33.33% of the samples from the unofficial market were found to be non-compliant.
Proportion of non-compliance by active ingredient (Fig. 6)
The results showed a significantly higher non-compliance (P = 0.028) with ISM (73.91%) compared to DA (50%). However, no significant difference was observed between the two sources of supply (P = 0.057 and P = 0.178 for the official and unofficial sources, respectively). Logistic regression using the country of purchase, the source (official or not) and active ingredient (ISM or DA) as explanatory variables revealed statistically significant effects of the active ingredient (P = 0.014) and country (P = 0.013) (Table 2).
The use of good quality trypanocidal drugs is required for an efficient treatment of AAT and for preventing the emergence of chemoresistance . It is also considered as a key component for sustainable, community-based AAT reduction in the framework of the Progressive Control Pathway for AAT . This study provides data on the quality of trypanocides in 6 French speaking, which are members of the RESCAO network in West Africa.
The high proportion of non-compliance obtained in the sub-region (51.90%) shows that trypanocidal drugs of sub-standard quality remain a major reason of concern. It should also be considered here that the current threshold of deviance for DA used by LACOMEV and for this study was ±10% , while the threshold recommended by the OIE is more stringent being only ±5% in the routine analyses of drug control laboratories . This means that the non-compliance would be higher than 51.90%, reaching approximately 76% with the threshold of ±5%.
Non-compliances were significantly different between countries and when compared to previous studies using the same ±10% threshold, the non-compliances were of the same order of magnitude: 32.63% vs 42.3% in Burkina Faso ; 50% vs 71.4% in Côte d’Ivoire  and 63.27% vs 40% in Togo . The same proportions of high non-compliances were observed in Senegal  and Cameroon .
Our study also showed that non-compliances were similar from the official and the unofficial sources of supply (49.45% vs 53.03%). The high proportion of non-compliance might not be explained only by poor conditions of storage, transport and/or handling, but probably also by a poor quality control during manufacturing . The lower price of the trypanocides sold in the unofficial market is particularly obvious by the weekly markets in villages, which are more visited by livestock keepers. According to the International Federation for Animal Health, the trade in unregistered and substandard veterinary drugs in Africa is worth $400 million annually - a size similar to the official market .
In the RESCAO network area, a significantly higher non-compliance was observed for ISM (73.91%) compared to DA (50%), but no difference was detected between the supply sources (official or unofficial). The non-compliance rates were heterogeneous between countries and observed for both for DA and ISM. In Togo, non-compliances were in agreement with the results of a recent study: 33.33% vs 19% for ISM and 65.22% vs 50% for DA . The regression model confirms that this non-compliance is linked both to the active ingredient and to the country. Despite the mandatory marketing authorisation delivered by the UEMOA for any veterinary drugs, more actions are needed to reinforce the control and the sensitization of the sellers and actors of the livestock breeding in each country. These actions will help to reduce illegal trade of poor quality trypanocides, and thus to prevent or reduce drug resistance in the RESCAO network area.
The results of this study on the quality of trypanocides showed a high proportion of non-compliant drugs used for the treatment of AAT in West Africa. This study did not take into account the presence of contaminants or impurities and the authenticity of trypanocidal drugs. This non-compliance compromises the efficacy of the treatment as well as boosts the development of drug resistance, which is already observed in several African countries. To limit the deleterious effects of the circulating sub-standard quality drugs, the following actions would be, through UEMOA: (i) to enforce the national and sub-regional regulations and laws on the quality control, importation, supply and use of veterinary medicines and (ii) to organise capacity building of veterinary personal and livestock farmers on a rational use of the available drugs.
African animal trypanosomosis
Centre International de Recherche-Développement sur l’Elevage en zone Subhumide
Food and Agriculture Organization
Global Alliance for Livestock Veterinary Medicine
Gross domestic product
High performance liquid chromatography
International Atomic Energy Agency
International Federation for Animal Health
Laboratoire de Contrôle des Médicaments Vétérinaires
World Organisation for Animal Health
Réseau d’épidemiosurveillance de la chimiorésistance aux trypanocides et acaricides en Afrique de l’Ouest
Union Economique et Monétaire Ouest Africaine
Renard JF, Cheikh L, Knips V. L’élevage et l’intégration régionale en Afrique de l’Ouest. Rapport du Ministère des Affaires Etrangères, FAO-CIRAD-EMVT. 2004. p. 37. http://catalogue-bibliotheques.cirad.fr/cgi-bin/koha/opac-detail.pl?biblionumber=181837. Accessed 10 June 2018.
SWAC-OECD/ECOWAS. Livestock and regional market in the Sahel and West Africa: potentials and challenges. Paris: Sahel and West Africa Club/OECD; 2008. p. 150.
Diall O, Cecchi G, Wanda G, Argiles-Herrero R, Vreysen MJB, Cattoli G, et al. Developing a progressive control pathway for African animal Trypanosomosis. Trends Parasitol. 2017;33:499–509.
Swallow BM. PAAT position paper: Impacts of African animal trypanosomosis on migration, livestock and crop production. Rome: FAO-OMS-IAEA-OAU/IBAR; 1998. p. 1–19.
Kone N, Bouyer F, Vitouley HS, Sidibe I, N'Goran EK, Vial L, et al. Perceptions des éleveurs et stratégies de gestion du risque trypanosomien dans le bassin du fleuve Mouhoun (Burkina Faso). Cah Agric. 2012;21:404–16.
Bouyer J, Seck MT, Sall B. Misleading guidance for decision making on tsetse eradication: response to Shaw et al. (2013). Prev Vet Med. 2013. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2013.05.017.
Kabayo JP. Aiming to eliminate tsetse from Africa. Trends Parasitol. 2002;18:473–5.
Dicko AH, Percoma L, Sow A, Adam Y, Mahama C, Sidibé I, et al. A Spatio-temporal model of African animal Trypanosomosis risk. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015;9(7):e0003921. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0003921.
Percoma L, Sow A, Pagabeleguem S, Dicko AH, Serdebéogo O, Ouédraogo M, et al. Impact of an integrated control campaign on tsetse populations in Burkina Faso. Parasit Vectors. 2018;11:270.
Vreysen MJB, Balenghien T, Saleh KM, Maiga S, Koudougou Z, Cecchi G, et al. Release-recapture studies confirm dispersal of Glossina palpalis gambiensis between river basins in Mali. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2013;7(4):e2022. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0002022.
Kinabo LD. Pharmacology of existing drugs for animal trypanosomiasis. Acta Trop. 1993;54:169–83.
Magez S, Caljon G, Tran T, Stijlemans B, Radwanska M. Current status of vaccination against African trypanosomiasis. Parasitology. 2010;137:2017–27.
Magez S, Radwanska M. African trypanosomiasis and antibodies: implications for vaccination, therapy and diagnosis. Future Microbiol. 2009;4:1075–87.
Sones K. Pharmaceutical companies: Partners or enemies. ICPTV Newsletter. 2001;3:19–21.
Sutcliffe OB, Skellern GG, Araya F, Cannavan A, Sasanya JJ, Dungu B, et al. Animal trypanosomosis: making quality control of trypanocidal drugs possible. Rev Sci Tech Off Int Epizoot. 2014;33:1–42.
Coulibaly H. Organisation des services vétérinaires dans les pays en développement d’Afrique de l’Ouest. Rev Sci Tech Off Int Epizoot. 2004;23:361–73.
Grace D, Randolph T, Affognon H, Dramane D, Diall O, Clausen PH. Characterisation and validation of farmers’ knowledge and practice of cattle trypanosomosis management in the cotton zone of West Africa. Acta Trop. 2009;111:137–43.
Mungube EO, Diall O, Baumann MP, Hoppenheit A, Hinney B, Bauer B, et al. Best-bet integrated strategies for containing drug-resistant trypanosomes in cattle. Parasit Vectors. 2012;5:164.
Daré I. Harmonisation de l'enrégistrement et du contrôle des médicaments vétérinaires en Afrique: L'exemple de l'Union Economique et Monétaire Ouest-Africaine (UEMOA). In: 17ème Conférence de la commission régionale de l’OIE pour l’Afrique, Asmara, Erythrée; 2007. p. 133–47.
Tchamdja E, Kulo AE, Akoda K, Teko Agbo A, Assoumi AM, Niang E, et al. Drug quality analysis through high performance liquid chromatography of isometamidium chloride hydrochloride and diminazene diaceturate purchased from official and unofficial sources in northern Togo. Prev Vet Med. 2016;126:151–8.
Vitouley HS, Bengaly Z, Adakal H, Sidibe I, Van Den Abbeele J, Delespaux V. Réseau d’EpidémioSurveillance de la Chimiorésistance aux trypanocides et aux acaricides en Afrique de l’Ouest (RESCAO). Tropicultura. 2013;31:205–12.
Tchamdja E. Etude de la prévalence des résistances aux trypanocides dans les régions de la Kara et des Savanes au Togo. In: Rapp. terrain. Proj. TRYRAC, Direction l’Elevage, Lomé, Togo; 2013. p. 25.
Talaki E, Sidibé I, Diall O, Affognon H, Grace D, Djiteye A, et al. Variations saisonnières et facteurs de risques des trypanosomoses animales dans un contexte de chimiorésistance dans la zone de Sikasso au Mali. Bulletin of Animal Health and Production in Africa. 2009;57:149–60.
Tettey JNA, Astriku C, Chizyuka G, Slingenbergh J. Non conformance of diminazene preparations to manufacturers’ label claims: an extra factor in the development of chemoresistance? Newsl Integr Control Pathog Trypanos Vectors. 2002;5:24–5.
Clausen PH, Bauer B, Zessin KH, Diall O, Bocoum Z, Sidibe I, et al. Preventing and containing trypanocide resistance in the cotton zone of West Africa. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2010;57:28–32.
Teko-Agbo A, Assoumy AM, Akoda K, EMM N, PLJ BH. Qualité pharmaceutique des médicaments antiparasitaires vétérinaires au Burkina Faso. Rev Africaine Santé Prod Anim. 2011;9:3–7.
Assoumy AM, Teko-Agbo A, Akoda K, Niang EMM, Oulai J. Qualité pharmaceutique des médicaments vétérinaires en Côte d’Ivoire: cas du district d’Abidjan. Rev Africaine Santé Prod Anim. 2010;8:149–53.
Akoda K, Walbadet L, Niang EMM, Teko-Agbo A. Qualité des médicaments vétérinaires en circulation au Sénégal. Rev Africaine Santé Prod Anim. 2008;6:29–33.
Teko-Agbo A, Akoda K, Assoumy AM, Kadja MC, Niang EMM, Messomo Ndjana F, et al. Qualité des médicaments vétérinaires en circulation au Cameroun et au Sénégal. Dakar Méd. 2009;54:226–34.
FAO. Alliance to combat black market in counterfeit veterinary drugs. 2012. http://www.fao.org/news/story/en/item/123165/icode. Accessed 17 May 2017.
Authors wish to thank (i) the national system of agronomy in different countries for facilitating the sampling of trypanocidal drugs and (ii) LACOMEV in Senegal for drug quality analysis.
The DGCD Belgium (Direction Générale de la Coopération au Développement) financed part of this study through the Institutional Collaboration Framework Agreement 3 (2008–2013) with the Centre International de Recherche-Développement sur l’Elevage en zone Subhumide (CIRDES). The study was also supported by UEMOA-PACER (Programme d’Appui et de développement des Centres d’Excellence Régionaux) from 2012 to 2013. The FAO assistance to this study was provided in the framework of the Programme Against African Trypanosomosis (PAAT), and supported by the Government of Italy (Project ‘Improving food security in sub-Saharan Africa by supporting the progressive reduction of tsetse-transmitted trypanosomosis in the framework of the NEPAD’, codes GTFS/RAF/474/ITA and GCP/RAF/502/ITA).
Availability of data and materials
The datasets used and/or analysed during this study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The identity of sellers in whom the trypanocidal drugs were purchased in official source and unofficial one (local markets or street vendors) were kept confidential.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.