Effect of pre-analytical treatments on bovine milk acute phase proteins
BMC Veterinary Research volume 12, Article number: 151 (2016)
Samples for diagnostic procedures often require some form of pre-analytical preparation for preservation or safe handling during transportation prior to analysis in the laboratory. This is particularly important for milk samples which frequently need preservatives to retain milk composition as close to that found in freshly collected samples as possible.
Milk samples were treated by heating at 56 °C for 30 min or preserved by addition of either potassium dichromate or bronopol respectively. Haptoglobin (Hp), mammary associated serum amyloid A3 (M-SAA3) and C-reactive protein (CRP) were measured in the various treatment groups and in control samples which were not treated, using enzyme linked immunoassays. The concentrations of each APP were compared between treated and non-treated groups using the Wilcoxon signed ranks tests.
Heat treatment of samples was found to have a significant lowering effect on milk M-SAA3 and CRP but not Hp. The use of potassium dichromate and bronopol as preservatives in milk had no significant effects on milk Hp and M-SAA3 concentration but lowered milk CRP values compared to controls.
The observed effects of heating and preservative use on milk APP should be taken into consideration when assaying samples which have undergone heat treatment as a result of international transfer regulations involving biological samples or samples needing chemical preservation prior to transport to laboratory.
Acute phase proteins are continuing to gain importance particularly as diagnostic tools in veterinary medicine . With the discovery of the major APP in bovine milk and its correlation with mastitis , there has been a growing interest of their exploitation as biomarkers of bovine mastitis which can be adapted to a rapid, on farm measuring format. Given that bovine mastitis is one of the most prevalent and costly conditions affecting dairy cows which greatly impacts on the economics, welfare and public health aspects of dairy farming, the substantiation of APP for mastitis diagnosis is on-going and methods to apply their measurement to a rapid format has been explored [3, 4].
Acute phase proteins are proteins that are synthesized in the liver and other organs in response to inflammatory stimuli and released into body fluids such as serum, milk , ovarian fluid  among others. These samples are therefore collected and assayed for APP in order to make clinical diagnosis of inflammatory and other disease conditions.
Samples for diagnostic procedures often require some form of preparation, preservation or safe handling for transportation prior to analysis in the laboratory. This is especially true for milk samples which frequently need the use of preservatives to retain milk composition as close to that found in freshly collected samples as possible. Chemical preservation is used to avoid cellular degradation prior to somatic cell counts (SCC) or progesterone analysis (pregnancy test). Storage at freezing temperatures of between −20 °C and −80 °C is also a common way of preserving milk samples.
In addition, as a requirement for the safe transfer of biological samples across international borders, some national regulations demand heat treatment of liquid samples in order to inactivate harmful pathogens in the samples have been put in place (for example; Council directive 82/894/EEC of 21 December 1982, under the European Communities Act 1972).
However, high temperature is known to denature proteins and to influence the concentration and immunologic activities of some serum proteins . Heat treatment has also been shown to result in irreversible changes in the structure of milk proteins . In addition, heating of milk has been shown to affect various characteristics of milk ranging from allergenicity of milk proteins [8, 9] to the concentration of water soluble vitamins, as well as concentration and activity of some milk proteins [10–12]. Furthermore, it was observed that heating colostrum to 60 °C for 60 min resulted in inactivation of pathogens and loss (although minimal) in colostral IgG . A number of other studies have also focused on the effect of heat on residues of drugs (quninolones, aminoglycosides) in milk [13, 14].
In the handling of milk samples for analysis, the use of preservatives has become a requirement for some tests due to distances of laboratories from the farms where samples are obtained. Potassium dichromate (K2Cr2O7) as in Lactab Marks III® is a corrosive and toxic biocide which is often used in the preservation of milk samples in order to maintain milk composition from time of collection to analysis. It is known to be effective as a milk preservative , and is used to maintain progesterone levels in milk for pregnancy diagnosis. Another broad spectrum milk preservative, bronopol (C3H6BrNO4; 2-bromo-2-nitro-1, 3 propanediol), which unlike potassium dichromate is reported to have no toxic effects, is often used particularly for preserving milk somatic cells prior to analysis through its action as an antimicrobial agent [16, 17]. Other preservatives that have been used in milk samples include Mercury chloride (HgCl2), sodium azide , Azidiol  and formalin .
Although the efficacy of these milk preservatives in maintaining milks’ natural composition including protein, fat and SCC has been proven [21–23], there has also been early reports [24–26] of alterations in analyte concentrations following the use of these preservatives. For example potassium dichromate was shown to lead to a decrease in protein concentration within 24 h after milk collection . In addition, bronopol based preservatives were shown to alter the mid infrared measurements of protein contents of milk samples . In another study however, the use of the preservatives potassium dichromate, bronopol and sodium azide did not significantly change fats, proteins, lactose and milk solids content of milk when samples were analyzed within 7 days of preservative use, but were reported to lead to a decline in these components when measured in samples stored for over 7 days after preservation . Use of bronopol has also been reported to yield higher values of % proteins and fat compared to values measured in aliquots of the samples following the use of potassium dichromate . Differences in effects on milk microflora between use of different preservatives have also been reported . Other parameters that have been reported to be affected by chemical preservative use include the electrical conductivity (EC) of milk by potassium dichromate .
From these reports, it can be inferred that there is a possibility that the use of chemical preservatives may affect analytes in milk. Indeed it has been recommended that where the preservative used in milk interferes with the analyte being tested; a suitable correction factor should be used .
It is not known if the use of chemical preservatives in milk meant for analysis or heat treatment of milk samples in order to inactivate pathogens before international transit, has any effect on the concentration of milk APP. It is important to be aware of such effects if they exist, if such treated milk samples are to be used for analysis of APP.
This study was carried out to evaluate the effects of heat treatment and chemical preservative use on milk APP concentration. This consisted of the assessment of milk Hp, M-SAA3 and CRP following the use of the milk preservatives; potassium dichromate (Lactab Marks III®) and bronopol (broad spectrum Microtab® II) for milk preservation after 24 h and heating samples to pathogen-inactivation temperature (56 °C) for 30 min.
Milk samples were residual samples from previously described investigations  and also the residue of milk from commercial dairy farms in the West of Scotland submitted to Veterinary Diagnostic Services, University of Glasgow, for evaluation for mastitis. The samples covered a wide concentration range of APP; encompassing low values in non-mastitic milk and high values as expected in mastitic milk samples.
After mastitis diagnosis the residual of each sample was made into aliquots, stored at −20 °C before being subjected to various pre-analytical treatments before APP determination.
Aliquots (~500 μl) were treated in one of the following ways described below, while control sample aliquots were not treated.
Heat treatment was carried out by heating milk samples at 56 °C for 30 min in a water bath after which they were analyzed for Hp (n = 59), M-SAA3 (n = 44) and CRP (n = 53) alongside controls (unheated).
To evaluate the effect of preservatives, another set of milk aliquots had 1 mg of potassium dichromate (Lactabs Mark III®, Thompson and Capper Ltd, Cheshire, UK) per 10 ml of milk sample added and allowed to gently mix and act for 24 h at 4–8 °C on a shaker. Subsequently samples were analyzed for Hp (n = 35), M-SAA3 (n = 18) and CRP (n = 20). A different set of milk aliquots had 8 mg (1 tablet) of bronopol (Broad spectrum Microtabs®, Advanced instruments, Inc., Massachusetts, USA) added to 40 ml of milk sample and gently mixed for 24 h at 4–8 °C. Hp (n = 54), M-SAA3 (n = 21) and CRP (n = 21) were also measured in these samples. Control samples (without any form of treatment) were also held at 4–8 °C for 24 h before analysis.
Acute phase protein assays
Samples were assayed for Hp using an in-house ELISA developed for measuring milk Hp as described in Thomas et al.. Dilutions were varied (ranging from 1:200 to 1:3200) from sample to sample depending on its Hp concentration, in order for the optical density value to fall within the interpolating range of the standard curve.
Mammary associated serum amyloid A
Tridelta Development Ltd supplied the Phase™ range SAA ELISA kit. Assay was performed as described in Thomas et al. . Sample dilutions were also modified to accommodate samples with very high M-SAA3 concentration samples (range of dilutions were from 1:125 to 1: 1000).
Cow C-reactive protein (CRP) ELISA kits for assay of bovine milk CRP were supplied by the Life Diagnostics Inc. (West Chester, USA). The assay was performed as described in Thomas et al.. Sample dilutions ranged from 1: 5 to 1:50.
Tests for normality of each APP data were carried out using the Kolmogorov–Smirnov and Shapiro–Wilk test along with normal probability plots and quantile-quantile (Q-Q) plots.
To assess the effects on each milk APP of heat treatment and use of preservatives: potassium dichromate and bronopol, the Wilcoxon signed ranks test (non-parametric) was used to compare treated and untreated groups. The Spearman’s rho correlation test was also carried out to assess the correlation between each APP in the different treatment groups. A P value of <0.05 was considered significant. All statistical analyses were carried out using the IBM statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) software; version 21 (IBM Corporation USA, 2012).
Table 1 shows the statistical observations from the comparison of three acute phase proteins values between various treated and untreated milk samples.
The intra-assay and inter-assay precision of the Hp ELISA were 6 % and 27 % correspondingly while the limit of detection (LOD) of the assay was 0.4 μg/ml as reported in Thomas et al..
No significant difference was observed between the milk Hp concentration of heated and unheated samples (P = 0.06) and a significant correlation between heated and unheated samples’ Hp was observed. The use of potassium dichromate and bronopol as milk preservatives for a duration of 24 h also did not result in a significant difference in milk Hp from controls (Table 1). Regression curves of concentrations of Hp in treated versus untreated milk samples are shown Fig. 1a-c. Table 2 shows the means and standard deviations of the concentrations in control and treated samples of Hp MSAA3 and CRP in the different treatment protocols.
Mammary associated serum amyloid A
Intra-assay and inter-assay CV of the MSAA3 ELISA was 7 % and 33 % respectively and a LOD of 0.6 μg/ml was established for the assay . The M-SAA3 concentrations in heated samples were significantly different (lower) than those recorded from the unheated samples. However use of either potassium dichromate or bronopol preservatives did not indicate a significant difference in the values of M-SAA3 in milk from control values (Table 1). Regression curves of concentrations of M-SAA3 in treated versus untreated milk samples are shown Fig. 1b.
Intra-assay and inter-assay CV of the CRP assay was 4 % and 7 % respectively and the LOD was 1.8 ng/ml . Heating milk samples was also observed to have a significant lowering effect on milk CRP values (P = 0.007). A significant correlation was observed between CRP values in heated and unheated milk samples (r = 0.97). The use of potassium dichromate and bronopol in milk was shown to produce a significant increase in milk CRP values compared to controls (P = 0.003, and 0.028 respectively) (Table 1). Regression curves of concentrations of CRP in treated versus untreated milk samples are shown Fig. 1c.
In this study, three pre-analytical treatments regimes were carried out on milk samples with the aim of comparing the APP values in treated and untreated samples.
Studies have shown that some protocols of heat treatment could have significant reduction effects on milk (colostral) proteins especially IgG [32, 33] and on lactoferrin . The observed lowering of M-SAA3 and CRP concentrations in heated samples and changes in CRP values of chemically preserved milk in the present study, lends further credence to these observations. It is generally known that high temperatures can result in the irreversible change in milk proteins structure , moreover it has been shown that aggregation of whey proteins can result upon heating of milk , this may explain some of the changes observed in the concentration of protein analytes in milk (which are mainly contained in the whey fraction).
It has been shown that high temperatures, can result in dissociation of CRP pentameres into its monomeric forms in blood , and although this may not affect the total concentration of serum CRP, it signals possible protein structural changes that are possible upon heating. There has been no report of the effect of heating on the structure of bovine milk CRP or M-SAA3. It can be inferred that a denaturation effect of heat on the protein structure or moiety of these compounds as reported by Hausen et al.  causes a loss of functional ability of these proteins to bind antibodies.
This finding should therefore be taken into consideration when assaying for M-SAA3 and CRP in samples which have undergone heating as a result of international transfer regulations involving heat treatment of biological samples. In such studies, control samples should be treated in the same manner as experimental samples or a correction factor based on the reduction in concentration should be applied. Structural changes in Haptoglobin have been associated with increased body temeprature (heat shock conditions) . However, no significant change in milk Hp concentration due to heating was observed in this study. Studies have shown good correlation between milk Hp and SCC [31, 38], and in the study of Hachana et al. , heating milk samples to 60 °C prior to analysis did not alter the Fossomatic SCC, although the duration for which samples were held at that temperature before analysis was not ascertained.
Only CRP concentrations were affected by the use of chemical preservatives in milk, with the concentration showing a significant increase following treatment with both potassium dichromate and Bronopol but the reason for this is not clear. Therefore samples being collected for SCC or for progesterone analysis can also be used for determination of Hp and M-SAA3 concentrations but should be cautiously used for CRP determination.
In this study, a minimum time of 24 h was used to assess the possible preservative effects of potassium dichromate and Bronopol and it is possible that samples preserved for longer (beyond 24 h) may develop changes that could significantly alter milk concentration of Hp and M-SAA3 as observed for some other proteins by Chalermsan et all . The milk used in this study were residual samples collected for either clinical investigation or prior experimental study and selected to give a range of APP concentrations. The effect of chemical preservatives was assessed after 24 h mixing and incubation at 4–8 °C in order replicate to some degree the likely treatment of samples between collection addition of preservative and analysis. While it would be ideal to assess the effect of heat and chemical preservation on fresh samples treated immediately, this was beyond the scope of the present investigation. In future investigation of APP in milk, where preservatives are being used to allow SCC or progesterone analysis, it would be of value to assess the effects on APP under a variety of conditions. Nevertheless, it is recommended that samples needing to be transported over long distances without any means of cold-chain storage, can be preserved using either potassium dichromate (Lactabs Mark III) or Bronopol (Microtabs), but should be analyzed as soon as possible and a correction factor should be applied in cases of CRP assay. It would be interesting to examine the effect of prolonged storage of milk with preservatives on milk APP.
Heating milk samples and preservative use in milk can affect the measurement of APP concentration. However, if this is recognized and taken into consideration when assaying milk samples which have undergone heat treatment, as maybe required to conform with international transport regulations, or when assaying samples needing chemical preservation, then APP analysis will give valid results especially when control samples are treated with identical procedures.
APP, acute phase proteins; APR, acute phase response; CRP, C-reactive protein; CV, coefficient of variation; ELISA, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay; Hp, haptoglobin; IMI, intramammary infection/inflammation; LOD, limit of detection; M-SAA3, mammary associated serum amyloid A3; SAA, serum amyloid A; SCC, somatic cell counts; SPSS, statistical package for social sciences; x, times
Eckersall PD, Bell R. Acute phase proteins: Biomarkers of infection and inflammation in veterinary medicine. Vet J. 2010;185:23–7.
Eckersall PD, Young FJ, McComb C, Hogarth CJ, Safi S, Weber A, McDonald T, Nolan AM, Fitzpatrick JL. Acute phase proteins in serum and milk from dairy cows with clinical mastitis. Vet Rec. 2001;148:35–41.
Åkerstedt M, Björck L, Waller KP, Stemesjö Å. Biosensor assay for determination of haptoglobin in bovine milk. J Dairy Res. 2006;73(March ?August2006):299–305.
Tan X, Ding SQ, Hu YX, Li JJ, Zhou JY. Development of an immunosensor assay for detection of haptoglobin in mastitic milk. Vet Clin Pathol. 2012;41(4):575–81.
Lavery K, Gabler C, Day J, Killian G. Expression of haptoglobin mRNA in the liver and oviduct during the oestrous cycle of cows (Bos taurus). Anim Reprod Sci. 2004;84:13–26.
Hausen BS, Signor C, Kober H, Tatsch E, Pereira RS, Duarte T, Hermes CL, Duarte MMMF, Moresco RN. Effect of temperature on albumin cobalt binding and its influence on ischemia-modified albumin levels in patients with suspected acute coronary syndrome. Clin Lab. 2012;169–172.
Raikos V. Effect of heat treatment on milk protein functionality at emulsion interfaces. A review. Food Hydrocoll. 2010;259–265.
Tiwari R, Wolber FM. Effect of heat treatment on stability and allergenicity of cow milk and goat milk proteins. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2010;125:53.
Bloom KA, Huang FR, Bencharitiwong R, Bardina L, Ross A, Sampson HA, Nowak-Wegrzyn A. Effect of heat treatment on milk and egg proteins allergenicity. Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2014;25:740–6.
Conesa C, Rota C, Castillo E, Pérez MD, CALVO M, SÁNCHEZ L. Effect of heat treatment on the antibacterial activity of bovine lactoferrin against three foodborne pathogens. Int J Dairy Technol. 2010;63:209–15.
Elizondo-Salazar JA, Jayarao BM, Heinrichs AJ. Effect of heat treatment of bovine colostrum on bacterial counts, viscosity, and Immunoglobulin G concentration. J Dairy Sci. 2010;93:961–7.
Morisawa Y, Kitamura A, Ujihara T, Zushi N, Kuzume K, Shimanouchi Y, Tamura S, Wakiguchi H, Saito H, Matsumoto K. Effect of heat treatment and enzymatic digestion on the B cell epitopes of cow’s milk proteins. Clin Exp Allergy. 2009;39:918–25.
Roca M, Castillo M, Marti P, Althaus RL, Molina MP. Effect of heating on the stability of quinolones in milk. J Agric Food Chem. 2010;58:5427–31.
Zorraquino MA, Althaus RL, Roca M, Molina MP. Effect of heat treatments on aminoglycosides in milk. J Food Prot. 2009;72:1338–41.
Barbano D, Wojciechowski K, Lynch J. Effect of preservatives on the accuracy of mid-infrared milk component testing. J Dairy Sci. 2010;93(12):6000–11.
Ardoe Y. Bronopol as a preservative in milk samples for the determination of cell content using Fossomatic. Milchwissenschaft. 1982;37:139–42.
Chalermsan N, Vijchulata P, Chirattanayuth P, Sintuwanit S, Surapat S, Engkagul A. Effects of preservatives on raw milk components analyzed by infrared spectrophotometry. Kasetsart Journal, Natural Sciences. 2004;38:38–43
Luck H. Determination of the fat protein and lactose content of 10 day preserved milk samples by means of the Ir milk analyzer. S Afr J Dairy Technol. 1975:75–78
Barcina Y, Zorraquino MA, Pedauye J, Ro GRF. Azidiol as a preservative for milk samples. An Vet. 1987;3:65–9.
Upadhyay N, Goyal A, Kumar A, Ghai DL, Singh R. Preservation of milk and milk products for analytical purposes. Food Rev Int. 2014;30:203–24.
Sánchez A, Sierra D, Luengo C, Corrales JC, Morales CT, Contreras AGC. Influence of storage and preservation on fossomatic cell count and composition of goat milk. J Dairy Sci. 2005;88:3095–100.
Sešķēna RJL. Influence of chemical preservatives on the quality and composition indices of raw milk samples. Acta Univ Latv. 2007;723:171–80.
Butler GSS. Suitability of bronopol preservative treated milk for fatty acid determination. J Dairy Res. 2011;78:220–5.
DA Coleman MB. Effects of several factors on quantification of fat, protein, and somatic cells in milk. J Dairy Sci. 1989;72:3295–303.
Monardes HG, Moore RK, Corrigan BRY. Preservation and storage mechanisms for raw milk samples for use in milk-recording schemes. J Food Prot. 1996;59:151–4.
Bertrand JA. Influence of shipping container, preservative, and breed on analysis of milk components of shipped samples. J Dairy Sci. 1996;79:145–8.
Ng-Kwai-Hang KF, Hayes JF. Effects of potassium dichromate and sample storage time on fat and protein by Milko-Scan and on protein and casein by a modified Pro-Milk Mk II method. J Dairy Sci. 1982;65:1895–9.
Benda P. The effect of some preservatives on natural microflora in milk samples. Vet Med (Praha). 1995;40:359–64.
Lien C, Young C, Chang HWY. Study on the effect of detection of preservative doses in raw milk samples. J Agric Assoc Taiwan. 2011;12:287–302.
The Effect of Bronopol on the Freezing Point and Impedance of Milk Samples. [www.aicompanies.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/EffectBronopol_Brochure_WEB.pdf]. verified 19 July 2016.
Thomas FC, Waterston M, Hastie P, Parkin T, Haining H, Eckersall PD. The major acute phase proteins of bovine milk in a commercial dairy herd. BMC Vet Res. 2015;11:207.
Johnson JL, Godden SM, Molitor T, Ames THD. Effects of feeding heat-treated colostrum on passive transfer of immune and nutritional parameters in neonatal dairy calves. J Dairy Sci. 2007;90:5189–98.
Godden SM, Smith S, Feirtag JM, Green LR, Wells SJFJ. Effect of on-farm commercial batch pasteurization of colostrum on colostrum and serum immunoglobulin concentrations in dairy calves. J Dairy Sci. 2003;86:1503–12.
Teixeira AGV, Bicalho MLS, Machado VS, Oikonomou G, Kacar C, Foditsch C, Young R, Knauer WA, Nydam DV, Bicalho RC. Heat and ultraviolet light treatment of colostrum and hospital milk: effects on colostrum and hospital milk characteristics and calf health and growth parameters. Vet J. 2013;197:175–81.
Wijayanti HB, Bansal N, Deeth HC. Stability of Whey proteins during thermal processing: a review. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf. 2014;13:1235–51.
Taylor KE, van den Berg CW. Structural and functional comparison of native pentameric, denatured monomeric and biotinylated C-reactive protein. Immunology. 2007;120:404–11.
Ettrich R, Brandt W, Kopecký V, Baumruk V, Hofbauerová K, Pavlícek Z. Study of chaperone-like activity of human haptoglobin: conformational changes under heat shock conditions and localization of interaction sites. Biol Chem. 2002;383:1667–76.
Pyörälä S, Hovinen M, Simojoki H, Fitzpatrick J, Eckersall PD, Orro T. Acute phase proteins in milk in naturally acquired bovine mastitis caused by different pathogens. Vet Rec. 2011;168:535.
Hachana Y, Kraiem K, Hani K, Haddad BPM. Effects of time storage and analytical temperature on Fossomatic cell counts in cows milk. Milchwissenschaft-Milk Sci Int. 2008;63:267–9.
The authors wish to acknowledge the management and staff of Cochno Research Farm for assistance in collection of milk samples.
The study was supported with funds from the Federal University of Agriculture Abeokuta/ TETFund, Nigeria and the BBSRC, UK (grant number BB/M022021).
Availability of data and material
Data supporting the findings of the study are available at the University of Glasgow archive at http://dx.doi.org/10.5525/gla.researchdata.319.
All authors shared the planning of the experiment. FCT, AMS and MW undertook the experimental procedures and conversion of assay output into APP concentration. Interpretation of data was performed by FCT under supervision of HH and PDE with PDE being the corresponding author. All authors contributed to the preparation and have approved the final version of the manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was covered by approval of the Ethics Committee of the School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Glasgow, reference number 31a/14 and UK Home Office license 70/8600.
About this article
Cite this article
Thomas, F.C., Santana, A.M., Waterston, M. et al. Effect of pre-analytical treatments on bovine milk acute phase proteins. BMC Vet Res 12, 151 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12917-016-0769-6
- C-reactive protein
- Thermal stability
- Mammary associated serum amyloid A3
- Milk preservatives