Skip to main content

Table 1 Demographical data, anaesthetic and surgical details of 132 dogs undergoing thoracolumbar (cranial to the 1st lumbar vertebra) or lumbar (caudal to the 1st lumbar vertebra) hemilaminectomy surgery and in which a bilateral erector spinae block (group ESPB) or a fentanyl infusion (group CRI) was used. Data are reported as mean ± standard deviation or median (range). Odd ratio (OR) and 95% Confidence intervals (CI) is reported when appropriate. * indicates reciprocal OR

From: Analgesic efficacy of a bilateral erector spinae plane block versus a fentanyl constant rate infusion in dogs undergoing hemilaminectomy: a retrospective cohort study

Group

ESPB

(n = 93)

CRI

(n = 39)

ESPB vs CRI

p value

OR

(95% CI)

Information

Age (months)

70 ± 34

71 ± 29

0.92

 

Sex (n. of dogs)

10 F (10.7%)

33 FS (35.5%)

18 M (19.4%)

32 MN (34.4%)

2 F (5.1%)

11 FS (28.2%)

8 M (20.5%)

18 MN (46.2%)

0.18

 

Body weight (kg)

10 (3.1–38.3)

8.6 (3.9–41)

0.29

 

MFS status (n. of dogs)

35 MFS-1 or 2 (37.6%)

53 MFS-3

(57%)

5 MFS-4

(5.4%)

31 MFS-1 or 2

(79.5%)

8 MFS-3

(20.5%)

0 MFS-4

(0%)

< 0.0001

5.87

(2.39–13.70) *

Pre-anaesthetic medication

Methadone

(n. of dogs)

93 (100%)

39 (100%)

1

 

Methadone dose (mg/kg)

0.2 (0.1–0.3)

0.25

  

Acepromazine

(n. of dogs)

1 (1.1%)

0

1

 

Acepromazine (mg/kg)

0.01

   

Dexmedetomidine (n. of dogs)

89 (95.7%)

0

< 0.0001

 
 

Dexmedetomidine (μg/kg)

1 (0.5–2)

   

Time from premedication to start of surgery (min)

85 (35–240)

90 (60–150)

0.18

 

Induction agent

Propofol

(n. of dogs)

85 (91.4%)

39 (100%)

0.10

 

Propofol

(mg/kg)

2.4

(0.9–5.4)

4.2

(2.4–7.8)

< 0.0001

 

Alfaxalone

(n. of dogs)

8 (8.6%)

0

0.10

 

Alfaxalone

(mg/kg)

0.9

(0.7–1.8)

   

Maintenance of anaesthesia

(n. of dogs)

90 Isoflurane

(96.8%)

3 Sevoflurane

(3.2%)

39 Isoflurane

(100%)

0 Sevoflurane

(0%)

0.55

 

MAC multiple IAA

0.94

(0.86–1.1)

1.08

(0.91–1.19)

< 0.0001

 

Type of disc herniation

(n.)

91 extrusions

(97.8%)

2 protrusions

(2.2%)

39 extrusions

(100%)

0 protrusions

(0%)

1

 

Lateralisation of herniated disc (n.)

51 left

(54.8%)

42 right

(45.2%)

23 left

(59%)

16 right

(41%)

0.70

 

Herniated intervertebral disc space (n.)

80 1-disc space

(86%)

10 2-disc spaces

(10.8%)

3 3-disc spaces

(3.2%)

39 1-disc space

(100%)

0 2-disc spaces

(0%)

0 3-disc spaces

(0%)

0.01

 

Type of surgery

Thoracolumbar

(n. of dogs)

62

(66.7%)

21

(53.8%)

0.17

 

Lumbar

(n. of dogs)

31

(33.3%)

18

(46.1%)

 

Disc fenestration (n.)

91

(97.8%)

36

(92.3%)

0.15

 

Number of discs fenestrated

3 (1–5)

4 (1–6)

< 0.0001

 

Surgical time (min)

70 (30–150)

65 (40–110)

0.17

 

Anaesthesia time (min)

161 ± 43

140 ± 31

0.01

 
  1. n. number; vs versus; F female; FS female spayed; M male; MN male neutered; MFS modified Frankel scale; MAC minimum alveolar concentration; IAA inhalational anaesthetic agent; min minute