Skip to main content

Table 3 Odds ratios, coefficients, and p-values of the association between epidemiological factors and herd-level Johne’s disease status, based on ELISA assays performed on individual milk samples in 600 herds in Minnesota

From: Use of a voluntary testing program to study the spatial epidemiology of Johne’s disease affecting dairy herds in Minnesota: a cross sectional study

Covariates

N

Univariable analysis

Multivariable analysis

Odds ratio (CI95%)

p-value*

β

S.E.

Odds ratio (CI95%)

p-value*

Herd size

  

< 0.001

   

< 0.001

 1 to ≤195

476

Ref

 196 to ≤553

100

1.67(1.39–2.02)

< 0.001

1.58

0.43

4.84(2.20–12.27)

< 0.001

 554 to 1929

24

13.74(2.86–246.87)

0.011

1.54

1.08

4.67(0.83–88.29)

0.153

Testing frequency

  

< 0.001

   

< 0.001

 1

208

Ref

 > 1 to ≤5

208

3.04(2.03–4.57)

< 0.001

1.03

0.21

2.81(1.86–4.29)

< 0.001

 6 to ≤20

80

13.15(6.16–32.64)

< 0.001

2.48

0.43

11.85(5.44–29.82)

< 0.001

 21 to 30

104

64.30(19.64–396.39)

< 0.001

3.77

0.73

43.34(13.00–269.33)

< 0.001

Soil type (texture)

  

< 0.001

   

0.017

 Sand

189

Ref

 Silt

115

2.87(1.69–5.01)

< 0.001

0.63

0.32

1.88(1.01–3.54)

0.047

 Loam

290

1.79(1.21–2.63)

0.003

0.63

0.22

1.88(1.21–2.93)

0.005

 Clay

6

3.59(0.56–69.51)

0.25

1.62

1.15

5.04(0.68–102.54)

0.162

Herd turnover rate

  

0.164

    

 18 to 37

192

Ref

     

 38 to 50

236

1.02(0.93–1.11)

0.698

    

 51 to 78

26

0.79(0.66–0.95)

0.014

    

Soil pH

  

0.004

    

 < 6.0

44

Ref

    

 6.0 to 7.0

467

2.15(1.14–4.03)

0.02

    

 > 7.0

89

2.21(1.05–4.70)

0.037

    

Hydrologic soil type

  

0.87

    

 A

57

Ref

     

 B

205

1.23(0.64–2.29)

0.527

    

 C

119

0.95(0.47–1.85)

0.874

    

 D

211

0.95(0.49–1.76)

0.872

    

Participation in VJDHSPa

 

0.84

    

 Non-participants

576

Ref

    

 Participants

24

1.09(0.46–2.87)

0.84

    

Agroecological zone

  

0.57

    

 Crop/Grassland

534

Ref

    

 Non-vegetated land

52

0.85(0.76–0.96)

0.76

    

 Shrubland

7

0.94(0.82–1.07)

0.50

    

 Deciduous Forest

7

1.08(0.95–1.22)

0.50

    

Spatial dependence

 1 km

0

  

λ = N/A

  

 5 km

344

  

λ = 0.00

 

0.962

 10 km

519

  

λ = 0.03

 

0.171

 15 km

565

  

λ = 0.02

 

0.256

 20 km

580

  

λ = 0.01

 

0.157

 109.7 km

600

  

λ = −0.01

 

0.352

  1. *p-values from the Likelihood Ratio Test. Spatial correlation parameter (λ). a VJDHSP = USDA Voluntary Johne’s Disease Herd Status Program for Cattle program